Shipwreck
First reading of Shipwreck, the
second play in Tom Stoppard's trilogy the Coast of Utopia

Alexander
and Natalie Herzen (Stephan Dillane and Eve
Best) at the the National Theatre production
in 2002Today I read
Shipwreck,
the second play in Tom
Stoppard 's trilogy The
Coast of Utopia . I commented on
Voyage, the first play, a week or so ago. Like Voyage, Shipwreck is
about the Russian intelligentsia. but this time it centers around Alexander
Herzen and his wife, Natalie. After Herzen gets a visa to travel to
Paris to obtain help for his child Kolya, who is deaf, Herzen becomes deeply
involved with the Russian expatriate community. Michael
Bakunin , the major figure of Voyage is a supporting character here.
Bakunin's desire to have a revolution now and worry about the ideals later is
contrasted with the more sympathetic Herzen, who worries about the real
consequences of revolution. Stoppard does his usual brilliant juxtaposition of
ideas by having these very serious socialists constantly squabbly amongst
themselves. Natalie falls in love with George Herweigh while still in love with
Herzen, and it is interesting to watch these idealists, intent on mutual
ownership of property, trying to cope with their jealousy. The French revolt in
1848, while they are in Paris, but the middle classes make sure that property
rights stay untouched. By the end of the play, Herzen is disillusioned - he has
lost his wife and child, France has reverted to monarchy, and he wonders if
Russia's very backwardness in not having developed a bourgeoisie will make its
revolution purer than
France's.Stoppard successfully
mingles the grand historical sweep with real, human problems. The ideas are
clear - many historical figures make an appearance, including Ivan
Turgenev and Karl
Marx. Either this was
easier to follow, or having read the first one made it easier. If this one
followed another plays plot, it was not obvious to me. I found a bibliography of
links, that I found at The Complete
Review , which
follows:Shipwreck:
• Excerpts
from My Past and
Thoughts by Alexander
HerzenMichael Bakunin:
• Ira Nadel's Double
Act (also: Tom Stoppard: A
Life)
Posted: Mon - November 24, 2003 at 09:58 PM