Video Rom
It is not often that a book, especially a work of
non-fiction, moves and excites me enough to make me want to send its author fan
mail. While reading Jennifer Deger's
Shimmering Screens: making media in an Aboriginal
community (University of Minnesota
Press, 2006), I had to resist the urge to do so at the conclusion of each
chapter; only the rush to discover what insights and delights awaited me in the
next installment kept my fingers from the keyboard. Deger, who is a research
fellow in anthropology at Macquarie University in Sydney, has written a
brilliant book that offers an analysis of the ways in which one man, Bangana
Wunungmurra, took up the challenge of making video from the community of
Gapuwiyak in Arnhem Land in order to reinvigorate Yolngu
rom
(Law) and to pursue a personal redemption. It is a study of the impact of
Western technology in (and not necessarily
on) a
remote community, a memoir of how fieldwork changes the anthropologist, and a
meditation on the ways in which Yolngu and
balanda
can interpenetrate each other's worlds. If anthropology in recent years has
questioned the possibility of continuing to write conventional ethnography along
the lines of Lloyd Warner's classic study of the Yolngu,
A Black
Civilization (Harper and Bros.,
1937), then Deger's Shimmering
Screens achieves a new model for ethnography
in the 21st century. For while Deger's thesis may not be startling to students
of Yolngu culture, the manner in which she constructs her argument in support of
it is original and highly affecting.
[T]he genius of the Yolngu imagination lies in its ability to recognize the Ancestral in new contexts and to envisage a place within a modernity that does not imply a break with the past. The Yolngu imaginary allows for mimetic forms of adaptation--a play of sameness and difference--without necessarily invoking a sense of contradiction or loss. To see and make connections with the practices and priorities of the generations that have gone before, while taking up the possibilities of the modern and the technological--this is Yolngu contemporaneity: the shimmering screen of the television set is a site for revelation and ritual participation (p. 210).
In undertaking her fieldwork, Deger
hoped to examine how modern technology was being employed by indigenous
Australians, especially under the auspices of the Broadcasting in Remote
Aboriginal Communities Scheme (BRACS). She eventually settled in Gapuwiyak, a
Yolngu community that self-consciously was attempting to maintain itself as a
"traditional" community. Rock 'n' roll and disco were discouraged (even Yothu
Yindi); painting of ancestral designs on bark for sale in the
balanda
marketplace (as done in Yirrkala) was deemed a violation of the Law. Although
the community had received a grant of technology from BRACS, they had taken
scant advantage of it. Most people preferred to use the old loudspeaker public
address system for "community broadcasts" rather than to explore the
possibilities of radio. At first, Deger began her work in the community by
helping some of the younger men and women to operate and maintain the equipment
for the purpose of participating in the Top End Aboriginal Bush Broadcasting
Association (TEABBA). Once radio broadcasting was underway with Deger's
assistance, there was still little interest in film, and none at all in what
Deger thought of as "Culture," that is, the traditional song, dance, and ritual
of Arnhem Land. In this seemingly unlikely setting for video production, Deger
encountered Bangana, and the two began work on the film whose making is the
focus of this book.Bangana, like
Deger, was in his early thirties at the time. Deger's first descriptions of him
are thoroughly engaging: she notes, for example that he refused to answer to his
balanda
name, Alan, dismissing it as "just another Balanda four-letter word" (p. 19).
She shows us a warm, quick-witted man who accepted her as his adopted sister in
ways that no-one in the community had done before, and who had broad experience
in the variety of roles a Yolngu man can play in the
balanda
administrative apparatus. He was a man at ease in both cultures.
But there was a sad side to Bangana's
story among the Yolngu. Prior to Deger's arrival at Gapuwiyak, in the course of
an enraged, drunken feud with his brothers, Bangana had deliberately destroyed a
sacred clan dilly bag. This sacrilege earned him several months exile in
Darwin, and even after his negotiated return to the community, his place among
the Yolngu was uneasy. Bangana saw Deger's interest in both culture and
technology as a means by which he could once more find a place within Gapuwiyak
society, a chance to rehabilitate himself in the context of the Law. The video
that they made together offered a chance to redeem himself. Deger writes of its
significance:
In 1997, with the assistance of an indigenous television production company from central Australia, Bangana and I completed a major video project entitled Gularri: That Brings Unity. The video tells the story of Gularri, the sacred fresh waters that flow through the waterholes, rivers, and seas of Yirritja clan countries across northeast Arnhem Land. Infused with Ancestral potency, replete with layers of story and significances, Gularri, and the sacred sites associated with it, is an important source of Yolngu identity. For Yolngu of the Yirritja moiety, these water are a foundational source: not only do they and the rangga come from Gularri: they are Gularri. Gularri does not simply represent them, it is them (p. 138).
Earlier video production in Arnhem
Land often attempted to capture ritual or other elements of tradition culture
before they "disappeared." The pre-eminent example of this is Ian Dunlop's
Yirrkala Film
Project, a series of twenty-two films
commissioned in the wake of the 1971 High Court decision that opened the way for
bauxite mining on Rirratjingu and Gumatj land on the Gove Peninsula. Filmed
over the course of more than a decade, the
Project
documents enormous cultural change in and around Yirrkala, and preserves a
stunning visual record of important ceremonial activity, including the funeral
of the great leader Mawalan.In
contrast,
Gularri's
vision was to re-create, to re-present, to re-invoke ritual
(ngarra)
in a new way through the use of the multi-sensual medium of video. The visuals
focus on the waters of Gularri as they flow through the various clan lands from
the source at Bungirrinydji in the Mitchell Plateau to Bulumiri at the northern
end of the Wessel Islands. Often there is nothing in the frame but the
shimmering surface of the water. The human star of the film is the
dhalkara,
Charlie Ngalambirra, the ritual leader who calls out the names of the country.
His presence in the film provides the appropriate spiritual sanction and
authority, re-inforced when he is joined on screen at various points along the
way by representatives of the clans who are responsible for the section of the
country being filmed. Ngalambirra's singing, the music of his clapsticks, and
the sound of the water itself provide the soundtrack and enrich the film's
sensual delivery.Part of the genius of
Bangana's direction of the film lies in his choice of visual shots and,
remarkably, his ability to be non-specific in his instructions to the production
crew from CAAMA. What emerges is a picture of the country in which sacred sites
may be glimpsed, or may even be off-camera, but which are nonetheless present to
the knowledgeable viewer. In creating these fleeting images of country and in
close-ups of waters that conceal the
rangga
of the clans, Bangana invokes the essential interplay of inside and outside
meanings that characterizes Yolngu ritual. By integrating the span of the
Gularri waters into the length of the cinematic experience, he emphasizes the
unity of the clans and hence of Yolngu identity. If preserving the essence of
the Yolngu is the ethos of Gapuwiyak, Bangana attempts with his film to employ
the technology of western culture to revitalize the efficacy of ritual in the
face of the malaise of the mundane and the distractions of that introduced
culture. In video's inherent capacity for rebroadcast or re-viewing, he also
captures something of the essential, repeatable, nature of ritual. Deger's
splendid recreation of the night of its premiere on the local television station
leaves no doubt of his success. The normal hubbub of the community came to a
near complete halt:
The open-air basketball courts with their off-kilter hoops and fading court markings lay abandoned. There was no sign of family groups walking between camps, shining torches, and brandishing sticks for the cheeky dogs; no sign of the toddlers, their siblings, and cousins who play within shouting distance of the card games, nor their parents gambling under the streetlights. No headlights or sound of diesel motors, no ghetto-blasted reggae or Christian gospel tapes broke the night's subtle solemnity. Everyone, it seemed, had tuned in (p. 182).
What makes this book a revelation in
its own right is Deger's method of revealing what the significance of the
Gularri
video was to her, to Bangana, and to the people of Gapuwiyak and beyond. Her
analysis owes much to Heidegger's writings on technology in modern society; to
Eric Michaels' important studies of Warlpiri uses of media in the 1980s; to Faye
Ginsburg's work in the decades following Michaels; to earlier analyses of Yolngu
culture and ritual such as Ian Keen's
Knowledge and Secrecy in an Aboriginal Religion: Yolngu of
North-East Arnhem Land (Oxford
University Press, 1994) and Howard Morphy's
Ancestral Connections: art and an Aboriginal system of
knowledge (University of Chicago
Press, 1991). But it owes its success even more to the new strain in
anthropological work that turns the ethnographer's eye away from a focus on the
structural analysis of society toward the insights that are gained from the
direct and interpersonal experience of individuals, including the ethnographer
herself.Franca Tamisari, another
anthropologist who has worked extensively with the Yolngu, draws a useful
distinction between the two kinds of knowledge expressed by the French words
savoir
and
connaissance.
The former refers to knowledge gained through description, the latter to
knowledge gained through experience. Thus one may know
(savoir)
the geographical coordinates of Paris or Gapuwiyak in a way that that is
different from the way one knows the character of the city or the country
(connaissance).
(Franca Tamisari, "'Personal Acquaintance': essential individuality and the
possibilities of encounters," in Moving
Anthropology: critical indigenous
studies (Charles Darwin University
Press, 2006), pp. 17-36.) The initial
chapters of Shimmering
Screens are concerned with matters of
connaissance,
as Deger tells how she came to engage in the project of making media in an
Aboriginal community, narrates her deepening relationship with Bangana and his
family, and attempts to support the making of a video with the young man. A
central chapter tells of Bangana's funeral after his sudden death from a heart
attack at the age of thirty-seven, not long after the completion of the film.
This chapter functions like the Yolngu concept of
likan
(literally "elbow"), that which mediates or connects; metaphorically
likan
expresses "the pivotal significance of the Ancestral connection that link
things. places, people" (p. 247). Returning for his funeral, Deger discovers
that an important shift in how some members of the community use
images--especially of Bangana--has occurred as the result of their work
together. In the book's final chapters, Deger turns her attention to the video
itself, and to the extended process of reflection on her experiences in
Gapuwiyak and the surrounding country. These meditations enabled her to
recognize at last what Bangana was attempting to achieve and to extract the
savoir
that one expects from a scholarly
monograph.I don't wish to give the
impression that Deger indulges in memoir and self-examination: the
anthropologist as subject of her own ethnography is most definitely
not
the focus of this book. But she recounts her personal experience as a means of
delving into concepts that are critical to the reader's apprehension of how
Bangana succeeds in his bold venture of synthesizing Yolngu ritual and
balanda
technology. For example, in her Introduction (p. xxxi), Deger reproduces a
photograph of herself with Bangana seated, quite fittingly, in what looks to be
a slow-moving stream. She describes the photograph as a "family album" shot,
one that documents her presence in Gapuwiyak and her especially congenial, warm
relationship with Bangana.But the
photograph carries much more than this obvious meaning: it was taken by Deger's
mother on a visit to Gapuwiyak. Thus it reflects not simply Deger's familial
relationship with Bangana as his adopted sister but, almost invisibly, their
shared relationship to her
balanda
family from Sydney. In revealing this fact, she made me suddenly realize how
often I take the photographer for granted, how infrequently I step back to
consider the relationship between the eye of the camera and the subject: when I
look at a photograph, I rarely stop to think who took it, and what the
relationship between photographer and subject might
be.Deger's point is much more serious,
however, for she uses this shot to establish how the mixture of the sensual (the
image perceived by the eye) and the cognitive (the knowledge that her mother was
the photographer) produces new meaning in the experience of looking at the
picture. In later chapters, Deger discusses the grief she lived through when
her mother and Bangana both died, within a year of one another. Thus the
layers of meaning carried by that photograph, of emotional connections made and
lost, become deeper and more resonant.
Similarly, at an earlier point in time
during her fieldwork, Bangana had visited her parents in Sydney where he
introduced himself to Deger's father by saying "Hi, Dad, I'm your black son from
Arnhem Land." Her father died while she was still working on
Gularri
with Bangana. Returning to Gapuwiyak afterwards, she showed Bangana a memorial
photograph that had been distributed to family members at the funeral. Looking
at it, he spoke "Bapa" (father), and she spontaneously gave him the photograph
as a memento, surprised at her sudden willingness to part with it. During the
weeks that she spent in Gapuwiyak for Bangana's own funeral, she discovered the
photograph of her father carefully stored among his most precious
belongings.Through these explorations
of the power of images, Deger in turn succeeded in engaging my own sympathies.
I went back and looked at the photograph of her and Bangana in the stream with
an altered recognition after learning more details of the story. And as I did,
I suddenly gained a new appreciation for the concept of successive revelation
that I had read about in so many ethnographic studies of the Yolngu: an
understanding of how deeper, hidden, inside meanings become revealed through
personal experience and repeated exposure. And because my sympathies had become
engaged, my memories of personal loss and grief activated by the story, I became
aware of my own part in this unfolding story. I felt like the eye behind the
camera, watching this story unfold, recording impressions, processing them, and
creating meaning for myself. In my empathy, I was "same but different," as
Yolngu say, with respect to this story. I had begun my reading of this book as
an attempt to gain
savoir
and suddenly found myself immersed in
connaissance.
And thus I came to understand how the Gapuwiyak community might be moved by
Bangana's filmed
Gularri,
and what makes it such an important
work
of culture, and not merely a
record
of culture.It is in this ability to
reproduce sensation, understanding, and experience through the medium of her
story and analysis in Shimmering
Screens that I believe that Deger has achieved
something quite remarkable. As my understanding and appreciation deepened
through the book's final chapters, I felt a bit of the rush of enlightenment
cascading over me. Quotations from Keen or Morphy (cited above) suddenly took
on new resonance. As she discussed the shots of moving water filling the
camera's frame my mind kept tugging me toward the bookcase, and when I finally
took down the catalog from Dreaming Their
Way and looked again at the image of
Galuma Maymuru's painting Yirritja
Dhuwa Gapu II, I saw with new clarity how the
representations of the moieties' waters mingled and separated, noted the curving
bands of one and the straight lines of the other, understood how they are
(again) same but different. Shimmering
Screens was truly a
revelation.The video of
Gularri
was replayed frequently in Gapuwiyak and broadcast on Imparja television for
several months after its completion and until the death of a Madarrpa woman who
appeared in it. Now, a decade later, Deger hopes to return to work with the
production team from CAAMA to create a DVD of the film, which will include some
additional, more recent footage. I, for one, am eagerly awaiting the chance to
see it. In the meantime, at least I can read the book again. For despite the
length of these remarks, I find that I have hardly done justice to all that it
contains.
Posted: Sun - May 6, 2007 at 01:29 PM
|
Quick Links
About this Blog
A collection of personal reflections and readings on the art of the indigenous people of Australia, their culture, anthropological studies, the art market, and whatever else strays across the cultural horizon.
If you don't wish to leave comments on the blog itself please fee free to contact me directly. Will Owen
Calendar
| | Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat
|
Categories
Archives
Past Posts, Selected
Technorati
Find It In a Library
Find It In An Australian Library
Creative Commons
XML/RSS Feed
Links
Statistics
Total entries in this blog:
Total entries in this category:
Published On: Jul 22, 2007 09:19 AM
|