| Toshiro Mifune, Koji Tsuruta , Kaoru
Yachigusa , Michiko Saga, Mariko Okada
Hiroshi Inagaki's Samurai trilogy comes to a dramatic conclusion
with part three, Duel at Ganryu Island. Musashi has tired of the
adventurous life and so returns to his roots as a simple village
farmer. His peace and tranquility are short-lived, however, as he
must deal with the dueling affections of Otsu and Akemi, battle
terrorizing brigands, and face a tough challenger in Kojiro Sasaki.
Much more dramatically uneven than the first film, the plot takes
more predictable turns this time around, is far less focused, and
several important characters from the first two episodes are given
short-shrift or are gone altogether (and the great Takashi Shimura,
playing a new character, is wasted in what amounts to a cameo).
The subplot involving bandits who make misery of the lives of the
rural farmers comes off as far too similar to Kurosawa's The Seven
Samurai, and the tacked-on climactic battle between Musashi and
Kojiro seems almost an afterthought. Still, like parts one and two,
Duel at Ganryu Island is at its best when focusing on Musashi, and
the role continues to offer Toshiro Mifune plenty of opportunities
to stretch his acting muscles. Physically and psychologically, Mifune
undergoes a stunning transformation over the course of the three
films, wild and buckish in part one, confident and swaggering in
part two, and finally wearied but somewhat content in the final
segment. The film, however, remains at its weakest when portraying
its women characters. As complex and layered as Musashi is, Otsu
and Akemi are shallow and at times insulting, coming dangerously
close to harming the film's overall credibility. Taken as a whole,
the Samurai trilogy is a remarkable achievement, and an underrated
classic of the genre. |