| N. Popov, Boris Livanov, Eduard Tisse
Borrowing its title from a book by American journalist John Reed
(of Reds fame), Sergei Eisenstein's Ten Days That Shook the World
reenacts the crucial week-and-a-half in October, 1918, when the
Russian Kerensky regime was toppled by the Bolsheviks. While Eisenstein
takes certain liberties in characterization--those opposing the
Bolsheviks are depicted as mental defectives or grossly overweight
clowns--his re-creation of such events as the storming of the Winter
Palace are painstakingly meticulous. The "actor" playing
Lenin, a nonprofessional worker named Nikandrov, so closely resembles
the genuine article that the effect is positively eerie. So authentic
is Eisenstein's reconstruction of events that, for years, TV documentaries
have been passing off clips from Ten Days That Shook the World as
"actual" scenes of the Revolution. While impressive on
a technical level, the film never truly stirs the audience's emotions;
Eisenstein purists have argued that this "alienation"
technique was the director's intention all along, forcing the viewer
to observe the events intellectually rather than emotionally. Produced
in celebration of the tenth anniversary of the October Revolution,
Ten Days That Shook the World was initially titled October. |