By Steve Waksman, Ph.D.
Printer-Friendly Version | PDF Version
Approximately 3-10% of all school age children have learning
disabilities, and such disabilities often lead to school failure,
poor peer relationships, low
self-concepts and limited work opportunities. Learning disabilities are frequently
accompanied by deficits in attention and social behavior, but are considered
different or distinct disorders from attention deficit disorders (ADHD) or conduct
disorders. The term learning disability refers to a wide range of disorders in
reading, writing, speaking, listening and mathematics.
The term dyslexia is usually
reserved for severe reading disorders. Reading disorders represent
the most common type of learning disabilities, accounting for 80%
of
all children diagnosed with learning disabilities. Reading disorders affect equal
numbers of boys and girls, but school districts currently identify four times
as many boys as girls.
How Are Learning Disabilities Diagnosed?
A precise definition of a learning or reading disability has not
yet been developed. There are over 50 different definitions in
the professional literature. Different
definitions are used by different school districts, different fields of professionals,
different researchers, and different clinics or professionals within the same
field. In fact, a student could be “cured” of his or her disability by simply
moving from one school to another due to differences in definitions and/or eligibility
criteria.
Most school districts use a definition which calls for a “severe discrepancy”
between a child’s measured intellectual ability and measured academic achievement.
The discrepancy may be in oral expression, listening comprehension, written
expression, reading recognition, reading comprehension, math calculations,
or math reasoning.
Other definitions include deficits in language, memory, processing speed, or
fine-motor skills. The discrepancy or deficit is determined through formal
IQ and achievement testing, although different professionals use
different tests.
Ultimately a multi-disciplinary school district evaluation team must determine
eligibility for special education services based upon their district’s policies,
and state and federal regulations. If a student meets the specific criteria
in his/her district, then s/he will be offered special education
services. If parents
agree with that decision, then the student’s parent(s), teacher(s), school
specialists, and if appropriate, the student must develop an Individualized Education Program (IEP) which specifies an education plan
for remediation with measurable goals and objectives. Many students have mild
delays in academics and are not eligible for special education services. They
may, however, be eligible for other types of academic remediation offered in
their particular school. They would also benefit from home tutoring.
Recent research
demonstrates that learning disorders occur along a continuum of impairment
and that distinguishing between disabled students with and without
an IQ achievement discrepancy appears to be an artificial distinction without
merit. However, school district policies must conform to Federal and state
regulations,
and most regulations still include a “discrepancy criteria”. Other research
demonstrates that learning disorders reflect a persistent deficit
rather than a temporary
or developmental lag. Over 70% of the third graders identified with reading
disabilities will remain disabled into high school and probably
adulthood.
What Causes Learning Disabilities?
There is a growing acceptance by scientists that reading disabilities
run in families and appear to be genetically determined. Researchers
have demonstrated
a strong link between some reading disorders and a chromosome abnormality.
There are many other studies demonstrating abnormalities or “pathologies” in
the brains
of individuals with severe reading disabilities. There is much less known about
the genetics or causes of less severe reading disorders, and other types of
learning disabilities. Certainly, inadequate opportunities, disruptive behavior
and/or
poor teaching strategies can contribute to academic delays.
The Importance of
Early Intervention
The ability to read and understand what is read depends on the
rapid and automatic recognition and decoding of single words.
Slow and inaccurate decoding skills
are the best predictors of reading comprehension problems, and future reading
disorders. A co-occurring disorder in attention, such as ADHD, will usually
exacerbate the severity of the reading disorder, and produce more cognitive
and social problems.
Since disabled readers do not easily learn the “phonic codes” due to their
disabilities, they must be provided highly structured programs which explicitly
teach the phonologic
rules and letter sounds. Well designed research studies funded by the National
Institute for Child Health and Human Development have convincingly demonstrated
that systematic phonics instruction, before the third grade, will result in
much more favorable outcomes for learning disabled students than reading approaches
utilizing a “context emphasis” or whole-language approach. Effective reading
programs also include intensive practice or repetition, comprehension and literature components, structured lessons,
and emotional support or encouragement.
How Are Learning Disorders Treated?
Besides early training in phonics, the only other intervention
with research support is tutoring in reading and basic skills.
This is usually provided through
special education services as “pull-out” classes or in-class assistance,
or by parents through private tutoring. Certainly a school
and/or home reinforcement
or reward system will keep students motivated and improve their effort to
learn. Also, counseling about the chronic nature of learning
problems, study skills
or learning strategies, and assistance with homework is helpful. Social skills
training for peer relationship problems, supportive therapy for depression
or
frustration problems and family therapy for family stress and/or child behavior
problems are also helpful. However, no other specific program, technique,
or medication has ever been shown to cure or alleviate learning
disabilities based
upon impartial research studies.
Learning disabled students (and adults) often require accommodations or modifications
in their school, work or home requirements. Such accommodations often include
less home work or chores, shorter assignments or tasks, the use of tape
recorders or computers, additional time to complete tests or assignments,
peer “note
takers” and alternative methods to “prove” one’s knowledge. The scheduling
of “resource
room” or “study skill” classes to allow students extra time to complete
assignments or homework is also very helpful. Just as physically
handicapped individuals
are provided ramps and special considerations, learning disabled individuals
need academic accommodations. It’s not only a good idea, it’s the law!
The Americans With Disabilities Act (ADA, P.L. 101-336) and the
Individuals with
Disabilities
Education Act (IDEA or P.L. 105-17, formerly P.L. 94-142) clearly require
“reasonable accommodations” and a “free and appropriate” education for
individuals with
learning disabilities.
Hopefully as educators, employers, and the general public learn more about
learning disabilities, fewer students will drop out of school early and
face limited employment
opportunities.
If you would like more information on learning disabilities,
attention deficit disorder, or behavior problems, please call:
Steven Waksman,
Ph.D., Licensed
Clinical Child Psychologist and Certified School Psychologist at (503)
222-4046. You may also receive information from your State Department
of Education.
Additional copies of this panphlet are available from the author at:
5441 SW Macadam Ave., Suite 206
Portland, OR 97239
Copyright
1996, 1998, Steven Waksman, Ph.D.
Top of Page
|