NTSB Accident Report - November 10,1975
About 1915 EST., on November 10, 1975, the Great
Lakes bulk cargo vessel SS EDMUND FITZGERALD, fully loaded with a cargo of
taconite pellets, sank in eastern Lake Superior in position 46 59.91 N, 85
06.6’W, approximately 17 miles from the entrance to Whitefish Bay,
Michigan. The ship was en route from Superior, WI, to Detroit, MI, and had been
proceeding at a reduced speed in a severe storm. All the vessel’s 29
officers and crewmembers are missing and presumed dead. No distress call was
heard by vessels or shore stations.
The
Safety Board considered many factors during the investigation including
stability, hull strength, operating practices, adequacy of weathertight
closures, hatch cover strength, possible grounding, vessel design, loading
practices, and weather forecasting.
The
National Transportation Safety Board determines that the probable cause of this
accident was the sudden massive flooding of the cargo hold due to the collapse
of one or more hatch covers. Before the hatch covers collapsed, flooding into
the ballast tanks and tunnel through topside damage and flooding into the cargo
hold through non-weathertight hatch covers caused a reduction of freeboard and a
list. The hydrostatic and hydrodynamic forces imposed on the hatch covers by
heavy boarding seas at this reduced freeboard and with the list caused the hatch
covers to collapse.
Contributing to the
accident was the lack of transverse weathertight bulkheads in the cargo hold and
the reduction of freeboard authorized by the 1969, 1971, and 1973 amendments to
the Great Lakes Load Line Regulations
THE
ACCIDENT:
About 0830 (all times are
Eastern Standard based on the 24-hour clock) on November 9, 1975, the SS EDMUND
FITZGERALD began loading 26,116 long tons of taconite pellets at Burlington
Northern Railroad Dock No. 1 in Superior, WI. This pier, known as a "chute
pier," is equipped with built-in storage bins, known as "pockets," which are
usually filled before a vessel arrives. Chutes are lowered from each "pocket" to
direct the cargo into the hatches of the vessel. Most of the "pockets" are
filled with 300 tons of taconite pellets; however, a few pockets are filled with
100 tons or 200 tons. These smaller amounts of cargo are used during the final
phase of loading to trim the ship for
departure.
Loading was completed about
1415 on November 9. The chief mate informed dock personnel that the
vessel’s final drafts were 27 feet 2 inches forward and 27 feet 6 inches
aft. Drafts were taken after receipt of the taconite pellets and 50,013 gallons
of No. 6 fuel oil, delivered by a barge which came alongside while the cargo was
being loaded.
Neither shipboard nor dock
personnel experienced difficulties while loading the cargo nor was any
difficulty or damage reported by the crew of the FITZGERALD. Shore side
personnel saw the ship’s crew replacing the hatch covers after
loading.
Upon departure at 1415, the
FITZGERALD proceeded at full speed of 99 rpm, approximately 16.3 mph. About
1630, the SS ARTHUR M. ANDERSON departed Two Harbors, Minnesota, with a similar
cargo en route to Gary, Indiana. Separated by 10 to 20 miles, the two vessels
proceeded on similar courses across Lake
Superior.
Because of predicted
deteriorating weather, the receipt of storm warnings at 0200 on November 10, and
discussions by radiotelephone, the FITZGERALD and ANDERSON departed the
recommended shipping lanes along the southern shore of Lake Superior, and
proceeded northeastward south of Isle Royal, then eastward along the northern
shore, and then southeastward along the eastern shore. This departure from the
recommended track allowed the two vessels to take advantage of the lee provided
by the Canadian shore. This is a generally accepted practice among Great Lakes
mariners to avoid adverse sea conditions during fall and winter storms when the
wind direction makes this lee available. During the first 10 to 11 hours of the
voyage, the ANDERSON was ahead of the FITZGERALD; however, about 0300 on
November 10, the faster FITZGERALD pulled slightly
ahead.
The FITZGERALD made routine
weather reports at 0100 and 0700 on November 10. In the normal morning report to
the company office, the FITZGERALD said her estimated time of arrival at Sault
Ste. Marie was indefinite because of bad
weather.
As the FITZGERALD and the
ANDERSON approached the eastern shore, the FITZGERALD proceeded farther east
than the ANDERSON before changing to a southeasterly course toward Michipicoten
Island. Since the FITZGERALD traveled a greater distance at a higher speed, the
distance between the two vessels remained almost constant. About 1252, the
ANDERSON was abeam Otter Island at a range of 10.8 miles, and the FITZGERALD was
8 miles ahead and slightly east of the ANDERSON’s track. (See figure 1.)
At that point, the FITZGERALD was about 17 miles north-northwest of Michipicoten
Island.
At 1350, the ANDERSON changed
course to 230 degrees
T to allow more sea room west of Michipicoten
Island because the wind was predicted to haul to the northwest. At this time,
the FITZGERALD was 2 1/2 to 3 miles southwest of Michipicoten Island, and she
advised the ANDERSON that she would "continue on" although she was "rolling
some." The FITZGERALD continued southeastward toward Whitefish Point on a course
of 1410 T while the ANDERSON proceeded southwestward to about 11 miles west of
Michipicoten Island and changed course to 130
degrees T at
1445. At this time, the FITZGERALD was observed to be about 16 miles ahead, a
position 9 miles south of Michipicoten Island. At 1520, the ANDERSON changed
course to 125 degreees
T at a position 7.7 miles southwest of
Michipicoten Island. The FITZGERALD was 16 miles ahead and slightly to the right
of the ANDERSON’s trackline.
About
1530, the FITZGERALD, then in a position northeast of Caribou Island, called the
ANDERSON and reported, "I have a fence rail down, have lost a couple of vents,
and have a list." The FITZGERALD further advised that she would
‘‘check-down’’ to allow the ANDERSON to close the
distance between the vessels. The ANDERSON asked the FITZGERALD if the pumps
were going and the reply was, "Yes, both of
them."
About 1610, the FITZGERALD advised
the ANDERSON that both her radars were inoperative and asked that the ANDERSON
keep track of the FITZGERALD and provide navigational assistance. At 1634, the
ANDERSON changed course to 141 degrees
T in a position 7.5 miles, 035 degrees T from
the north end of Caribou Island and observed the FITZGERALD 14 to 15 miles ahead
and slightly to the right of the ANDERSON’s heading flasher. At 1728, the
ANDERSON fixed her position 10.5 miles east of Caribou Light, determined that
the FITZGERALD was 15 miles ahead and slightly left (east) of the
ANDERSON’s heading flasher, and advised the FITZGERALD that Whitefish
Point was 35 miles from the FITZGERALD on a bearing of 144
degrees T.
The FITZGERALD replied that she "wanted to be 2 1/2 miles off Whitefish Point,"
and appeared to be steering for that
position.
About 1639, the Coast Guard
station at Grand Marais, MI, advised the FITZGERALD, in response to her inquiry,
that the radio beacon at Whitefish Point was not
operating.
Between 1700 and 1730, a Great
Lakes registered pilot on board the northbound Swedish vessel AVAFORS, in a
position near Whitefish Point, answered a call from the FITZGERALD and said that
Whitefish Point Light was operating but that the radio beacon was still off.
During a radiotelephone conversation between the two vessels, the master of the
FITZGERALD apparently spoke to personnel aboard the FITZGERALD while the
radiotelephone remained on the transmit mode. The master was overheard saying,
"Don’t allow nobody on deck," followed by some conversation concerning a
vent, which was not understood aboard the AVAFORS. The master advised the
AVAFORS that the FITZGERALD had a "bad list," had lost both radars, and was
taking heavy seas over the deck in one of the worst seas he had ever
encountered.
About 1820, the ANDERSON
advised the FITZGERALD that the FITZGERALD was working to the left of the
ANDERSON’s heading of 1420 T and determined by radiotelephone that the
FITZGERALD was steering 141 degrees T.
At
1900, the ANDERSON advised the FITZGERALD that she was 10 miles ahead and 1 to 1
1/2 miles to the left (east) of the ANDERSON’s heading flasher. At 1910,
the ANDERSON advised the FITZGERALD of northbound traffic 9 miles ahead of her.
In response to a question about her problems, the FITZGERALD replied, "We are
holding our own."
This was the last
radiotelephone conversation with the FITZGERALD. When the ANDERSON’s
radarscope was checked about 1920, there was no radar contact with her.
Visibility increased about this time and although lights on shore more than 20
miles away and lights of a northbound vessel 19 miles away could be seen, the
FITZGERALD, which should have been approximately 10 miles away, was not
visible.
Between 1920 and 2030, the
ANDERSON tried calling the FITZGERALD on VHF-FM radiotelephone, but got no
response. At 2032, the ANDERSON notified the Coast Guard that the FITZGERALD may
have suffered a casualty.
Wreckage
identified as that of the FITZGERALD was located in position 46 59.91 N’,
85 06.6’ W in 530 feet of water in eastern Lake Superior just north of the
International Boundary in Canadian waters. This position correlates with the
last position of the FITZGERALD as reported by the
ANDERSON.
Crew
Information
The crew of the
FITZGERALD consisted of the following 29 persons: a master, 3 licensed deck
officers, a chief engineer, 4 licensed engineering officers, and 20 unlicensed
personnel. No survivors were found and no bodies were
recovered.
The master and chief mate were
experienced Great Lakes mariners, having been licensed since 1938 and 1941,
respectively. Both men held valid licenses as Master and First Class Pilot for
Great Lake vessels of any gross tonnage. The other mates held valid licenses as
First Class Pilot for Great Lakes vessels of any gross tonnage which were first
issued in 1969 and 1973, respectively. The engineering officers were similarly
experienced.
The master had been employed
by the vessel’s operator since 1938, had been employed as master since
1951, and had served as master of the FITZGERALD since April
1972.
The chief mate had been employed by
the vessel’s operator since 1947 in various capacities, including relief
master in 1966 and 1971,’ and had served aboard the FITZGERALD as chief
mate since April
1975.
Vessel
Information
The FITZGERALD was one
of a fleet of 14 to 18 vessels operated by the Columbia Transportation Division
between 1972 and 1977. The Coast Guard casualty records for the company fleet
did not reveal any heavy weather damage during this
period.
The FITZGERALD was a conventional
"straightdecker" Great Lakes bulk cargo vessel. (See figure 2.) It was 729 feet
long, 75 feet in breadth, 39 feet in depth, 13,632 gross tons, and 8,686 net
tons. It was propelled by a 7,500-hp, steam turbine and was built as Hull 301 at
Great Lakes Engineering Works, River Rouge, Michigan, in 1958. The vessel was
owned by Northeastern Mutual Life Insurance Company and operated by the Columbia
Transportation Division of the Oglebay Norton
Company.
The vessel had a
860,950-cubic-foot cargo hold divided by two nonwatertight transverse "screen"
bulkheads. Outboard and below the cargo hold were eight ballast tanks divided at
the centerline into port and starboard tanks. (See figure 2.) The forward
deckhouse contained the pilot house and accommodations for the deck crew. The
engine room was located aft, above which were the rest of the accommodations and
the crew’s messing facilities. Below the weather deck and above the
ballast tanks were two tunnels, one port and one starboard, used for access
between the accommodation areas during adverse weather. The sheer strake
extended 15 3/8 inches above the weather deck at side and was connected to the
stringer plate by a riveted gunwale
bar.
There were 21 cargo hatch openings.
Each opening measured 11 feet longitudinally and 48 feet transversely and had a
24-inch coaming above the weather deck. Each opening was made weathertight by a
single-piece steel hatch cover. The hatch covers were made of 5/16-inch
stiffened plate with a 9/16-inch rubber gasket around the underside of the
plate’s perimeter. Each hatch cover was secured by 68 manually operated
"Kestner" clamps arranged on 2-foot centers. Each clamp had an adjustment bolt
which determined the force applied by the individual clamp and therefore
controlled the deflection of the hatch cover, the compression of the rubber
gasket, and the weathertightness of the hatch opening. There were no written
procedures concerning maintenance or adjustment of the hatch clamps or gaskets.
An electrically operated hatch cover crane which ran on rails outboard of the
cargo hatch openings was used for lifting the hatch
covers.
Access to the cargo hold was
provided through two 30-inch hatches through the weather deck located at the
"screen" bulkheads fitted on 24-inch coamings, through doors from the tunnels,
and through doors at the main deck level (i.e., the deck level below the weather
deck) at the forward and after ends of the cargo
hold.
Two 8-inch-diameter vent pipes
which extended 18 inches above the weather deck were fitted for each ballast
tank. The port and starboard access tunnels had similar vents extending 30
inches above the weather deck located forward and aft. In addition, each ballast
tank was fitted with a remote water level indicator device, called a "King
Gage," located in the lower engineroom near the ballast pumps. The only means of
detecting water in the cargo hold or access tunnel was by visual inspection.
Federal regulations do not require that Great Lakes vessels be equipped with
instruments to indicate trim or list.
The
bilge and ballast system consisted of a piping system connected through
manifolds and valving to four 7,000 gallon-per-minute main pumps and two 2,000
gallon-per-minute auxiliary pumps. The ballast system could be used to de-water
the cargo hold through two suctions located at the aftermost end of the No. 3
cargo hold, port and starboard. The tunnels could be drained by manually
operated drains connected to the ballast
tanks.
The following radiotelephone
equipment was located in the pilothouse and chartroom: Two VHF-FM, 12-channel,
25-watt radiotelephones operated from vessel’s power; one VHF-FM
12-channel, 25-watt radiotelephone operated from rechargable batteries located
in the pilothouse; one AM, 8-channel, 100-watt radiotelephone operated from
vessel’s power; one AM, emergency, 50-watt radiotelephone including
channel 51 (2182 kHz), operated from rechargeable batteries. The FITZGERALD also
had a radio direction finder and two surface scan radar sets. No fathometer was
required and none was installed.
After
her delivery in 1958, the FITZGERALD operated essentially unchanged until 1969
when a diesel-powered bow thruster was installed. During the winter of
1971-1972, the main propulsion plant was converted from coal to oil and the coal
bunkers were converted to fuel oil tanks. An automatic boiler combustion and
feed-water control system was installed as part of this
conversion.
Between 1958 and 1973, the
FITZGERALD was permitted three reductions in the minimum freeboard required by
46 CFR Part 45. (Freeboard on the FITZGERALD was the distance from the maximum
draft permitted to the weather deck at side.) A comparison of the requirements
for Great Lakes cargo vessels and those for vessels operating on the oceans
shows that for vessels of similar dimensions, the freeboard required for a Great
Lakes Load Line and that required for ocean service would be approximately the
same. However, the longitudinal strength required for a Great Lakes vessel is
approximately one—half that required for a vessel in ocean
service.
Posted: Tue - December
7, 2004 at 06:41 PM