Sir Steven Runciman
Scholar, linguist and
gossip, whose revisionist History of the Crusades and
studies of Byzantium were
massively researched and widely read
Steven Runciman was
famous for throwing light on some very dark ages, and
attempting, as he said the
historian must, "to record in one great sweeping
sequence the greater events
and movements that have swayed the destiny of
man". But as well as being
the leading historian of the Crusades, he was a
world traveller, the companion
of royalty - at least four queens were said
to have turned out for his
80th birthday - and an aficionado of the foibles
of the powerful, whether
past or present. Details of forgotten personalities
glint in all his writings,
and he could discourse about ancient genealogies,
scandals and feuds until
the crusaders came home.
His most important work,
the three- volume History of the Crusades, took a more sceptical line
than any previous Western
historian, and was freshly informed by a reading
of Islamic sources. Two
hundred years earlier Gibbon had portrayed the
crusades as doomed romantic
escapades, and wrote of "the triumph of
barbarism and superstition".
But in Runciman's eyes the crusaders were not a
chivalrous host who captured
but failed to keep the Holy Land: they were the
final wave of the barbarian
invaders who had destroyed the Roman Empire.
They completed this work
by destroying the real centre of medieval
civilisation and the last
bastion of antiquity, Constantinople and the
Byzantine Empire. In charting
the medieval phase of the endless struggle
between East and West in
the Middle East, Runciman's sympathies were
unambiguously with Byzantium
against the bigots and wreckers of the West.
His final judgment of the
whole enterprise set a standard of
self-laceration which British
historians have since struggled to surpass:
"High ideals were besmirched
by cruelty and greed, enterprise and endurance
by a blind and narrow self-righteousness;
and the Holy War itself was
nothing more than a long
act of intolerance in the name of God, which is a
sin against the Holy Ghost."
James Cochran Stevenson Runciman
was the second son of Walter Runciman, the first Viscount.
His paternal grandfather
was a Geordie of Scots descent who ran away to sea at 11, was a master
mariner by 21 and founded
a shipping line. His maternal grandfather ran a
chemical works in Jarrow.
His parents were both Liberal MPs - the first
married couple to sit together
in the Com- mons - so he knew Winston
Churchill from before the
First World War. His best friend at Summer Fields
prep school was the son
of Herbert Asquith, and in 1991 he claimed to have
known every Prime Minister
of the century except Campbell Bannerman, who
died when he was three,
and Bonar Law, "whom nobody knew".
He was a linguist from the
age of three, when his governess began to teach him
French. Latin followed at
six, Greek at seven, and Russian at 11. With these
accomplishments and a budding
interest in history, he was a King's Scholar
at Eton, and from there
he won a scholarship to Trinity College, Cambridge.
His mother had taken a first
in history at Girton, and he followed her
example with a first in
1925. He soon became a fellow of Trinity and a
university lecturer. His
rooms in Nevile's Court were famous for their
French 1820s grisaille wallpaper,
depicting Cupid and Psyche, and his
exquisite bric-a-brac. He
kept a green parakeet called Benedict, which he
use to spank with a pencil
for misdemeanours. He was already immensely
grand, and loved socialising.
As well as books and pictures - including
Edward Lear watercolours
- he collected anecdotes and people, and the names
in his gossip did not so
much drop as float diaphanously. He was a
broad-gauge gossip, ranging
across the academic, literary, social and royal
spheres with tales and tittle-tattle
about many generations in manycountries.
A typical example was his
story of the Queen of the Belgians who
had one of the first facelifts,
and was left with a permanent smile, so that
when the King died she had
to return to the clinic to have it let down
again.
Through his Eton friend Dadie
Rylands, now a young don at
King's, Runciman met John
Maynard Keynes, and through Keynes's wife, Lydia
Lopakova, he met Diaghilev.
Rylands also introduced him to the Bloomsbury
circle around Virginia Woolf
(whom Runciman never much cared for). Lytton
Strachey's attacks on the
then accepted greatness of the British Empire
formed a precedent for Runciman's
growing scepticism about much earlier
attempts at conquest; and
the enthusiasm of Roger Fry and Clive Bell helped
to foster his interest in
Byzantine art. As a bachelor don he was a
guide, friend and teasing
mentor to a number of undergraduates, including
Guy Burgess and Noel Annan,
whose affection he won for life. He gave
intimate lunches and dinners
enlivened occasionally by telling the fortunes
of his guests, including
the odd king, by Tarot card. But his heart was in
travel and research, and
the historian George Trevelyan advised him to leave
Cambridge if he wanted to
write. So in 1938, having come into a considerable
fortune on his grandfather's
death, he resigned his fellowship at Trinity
(though the College made
him an honorary fellow in 1965).
During the war he was a press
attaché to the British legation in Sofia and then in
Cairo, and from 1942 till
1945 was professor of Byzantine history and art at
the University of Istanbul.
From 1945 until 1947 he was head of the British
Council in Athens - while
Osbert Lancaster was at the Embassy and Paddy
Leigh Fermor was at the
British Institute. He then devoted himself to
writing books, dividing
his time, when he was not on his travels, between
his house in St John's Wood
and the Island of Eigg, where he entertained
friends by showing them
the singing sands and the spot where the Queen of
Eigg beheaded numbers of
Christian martyrs.
At Trinity Runciman had produced
three books, written with the lucidity and grace that were to be
his hallmark. The Times
commended both The Emperor Romanus Lecapenus (1929)
and The First Bulgarian
Empire (1930), saying that "many happy flashes, both
of inspiration and phrasing,
show that he has studied his Gibbon to good
effect". These were followed
by the book that first made his name, Byzantine
Civilization (1933), which
in fewer than 300 pages conjured up a full
picture of Byzantine life
and thought, and it gave a much-needed new
dimension to medieval history.
In 1947 he published The Medieval Manichee,
which he had written in
part before the war and in which he pursued the
famous dualist heresy from
the Bogomils in Bulgaria to the Albigensians in
France. It was, however,
his great History of the Crusades (1951, 1952
and 1954), that made Runciman
known to a much wider public. No adequate
history in English existed
when he began, and he broke with his French
predecessors by telling
the story not just from the viewpoint of the West,
but also as Islam and Constantinople
had seen it. To do this he drew on
Greek, Armenian and Muslim
texts, as well as on more modern sources.
The book is a model of narrative
history. The three volumes are each
divided into five parts,
so that the reader primarily interested in one
facet of the story can find
his way without difficulty. But Runciman was
uninterested in historiography.
Not for him the sociological techniques, the
excursions into demography,
geography and economics of the Braudel school of
history. He told the tale,
he was readable, and his account was
authoritative - a standard
work for years to come. He continued the story
with The Sicilian Vespers
(1958).
In 1965 Runciman wrote his
most elegiac work, The Fall of Constantinople, once again making use of
multifarious sources, Muslim
as well as Greek. He had already explored the
political and theological
rift between the Catholic powers and the Orthodox
Greeks in The Eastern Schism
(1955), and there was a poignant sympathy in
his account of a civilisation
that knew itself to be doomed but would not
compromise its style of
life. He was to continue writing books on
Byzantine history for a
further 15 years, following the fortunes of the
Orthodox Church in captivity,
the theocracy, style and civilisation of the
medieval Greeks and the
relations of Church and State. His researches took
him often to the Balkans
and the Near East, where he had friends from many
walks of life. Even so,
he found time in 1960 in a splendid display of
versatility to publish The
White Rajahs, a study of the Brooke family in
Sarawak. To do this he had
to travel to the Far East, and soon afterwards
he travelled to South America.
All the time he was writing papers for
historical journals, but
these contributions to learning paled beside the
list of his lectures. As
well as such named lectures as the Waynflete at
Oxford (1953-54), the Gifford
at St Andrews (1960-62) and the Birkbeck at
Trinity, Cambridge (1966),
he spoke at many American universities, and was
happy to journey to the
most out-of-the-way places. He could be an
unforgetable lecturer, as
for instance when he spoke with melancholy
resignation on the last
days of Constantinople.
Runciman held public appointments
over many years. He was a trustee of the British Museum and a
member of the ad- visory
council of the Victoria and Albert. From 1974 he
was a vice-president of
the London Library, which two years ago gave a lunch
party to celebrate his 95th
birthday and the 75th year of his life
membership. He later marked
the anniversary in his own way, paying for a
long-overdue replacement
of the library's alarming passenger lift. He warmly
approved the motto selected
for it from the Vulgate Book of Daniel: Plurimi
pertransibunt et multiplex
erit scientia ("Many shall run through it, and
knowledge shall be increased").
In Greece Runciman was welcomed as a
historian who did not talk
as if Greek history stopped with Alexander, and
who recognised that the
Greeks see Byzantium and the Orthodox Church as more
integral to their culture
than Sparta. He was paid the signal honour of
having a street named after
him in Mistra, the site which he celebrated in a
book published in 1980.
He chaired the Anglo-Hellenic League, and sat on the
board of the National Trust
for Greece. He held honorary degrees from
many universities and lectured
in more than a score of countries. He was
knighted in 1958 and appointed
CH in 1984. His last book, published in 1991,
was A Traveller's Alphabet
of places that excited his interest.
Brought up in Northumberland,
he loved the Border countryside and was
deeply attached to Scotland.
When his family sold Eigg he removed to
Dumfriesshire where he lived
in a peel tower near Lochmaben. He sat on the
councils of the National
Trust for Scotland and the Museum of Antiquities,
and took a lively interest
in the Scottish Ballet. When guests sang Scottish
songs, he liked to accompany
them with plenty of legato. Tall and
large-boned, with auburn
hair glinting, he would glide into a party and soon
be surrounded. His quizzical,
expressive face would register alarm,
amusement and incredulity
as he told stories or listened to others. Not much
given to ponderous discussion
and sceptical about schemes to improve the
world, he stood by his division
of people into two groups, first made at
Eton: the agreeable and
the "sillies" (among whom, of course, were numbered
many clever fools). His
capacity for friendship was remarkable, and not only
in this country but wherever
he went on his travels there are many who will
miss his wit and knack of
giving pleasure. He did not marry.
The Hon Sir Steven Runciman,
CH, FBA, historian, was born on July 7, 1903. He
died yesterday [Wednesday,
1 November, 2000] aged 97.
Sir Steven Runciman
SIR STEVEN RUNCIMAN, who has died aged 97, was the pre-eminent historian
of
the Byzantine Empire and of the Crusades; he was also a celebrated
aesthete,
gentleman scholar and repository of the civilised values of Edwardian
times.
His magnum opus was the three-volume A History of the Crusades, published
between 1951 and 1954. In its preface Runciman set out his credo, one
that
derived from Gibbon, derived from Gibbon, and stressed the claims of
grand narrative over narrow
analysis: "I believe that the supreme duty of the historian is to write
history, that is to say, to attempt to record in one sweeping sequence
the
greater events and movements that have swayed the destinies of man."
For Runciman, the Crusades were not romantic adventures but the last
of the
barbarian invasions, albeit ones that brought about the dominance of
Western
civilisation. His opinion was partly determined by his sympathy for
the
Byzantine Empire, often at odds with the Crusaders and an oasis of
culture
surrounded by unappreciative savages.
It was a condition with which he identified. His prodigious work on
a
culture previously damned as effete was largely responsible for the
blossoming of Byzantine studies in Britain.
His view of the historian's task - and his belief that one writes to
be
read - demanded that he aim as much at a non-specialist audience as
at
fellow academics. His lucid style was admirably suited to this, with
a
simplicity and dispassion that had been the ideal of Byzantine
iconographers. The popular success that his books enjoyed showed that
others
too came to enjoy the labyrinthine complexities of Levantine history.
They had in Runciman a surefooted guide who could render the past visible
and familiar, as in a memorable description of the messianic Peter
the
Hermit - "his long, lean face horribly like that of the donkey he always
rode".
James Cochran Stevenson Runciman was born in Northumberland on July
7 1903.
He was the second son of Walter Runciman, a member of Asquith's cabinet,
and
the grandson of a shipping magnate, Lord Runciman.
Steven's father was created Viscount Runciman of Doxford in 1937 and
the
next year led the mission that persuaded the Czech government to make
concessions to Hitler.
Steven's mother was the first woman to take a First in History at Cambridge
and the first wife of an MP also to secure a seat in the Commons. Steven
breathed a rich mixture of political gossip (he would go on to meet
all but
three of the 20th century's Prime Ministers).
One of his first memories was of waiting for suffragettes to carry out
their
vow to break the windows of the houses of Cabinet Ministers. With their
afternoon walk imminent, Steven and his young sister inquired of the
two
burly ladies waiting outside when their protest would begin, since
they were
anxious not to miss the fun. The campaigners left in a huff, and the
Runcimans' was the only house left undamaged that afternoon.
Steven could read Latin and Greek by the time he was six. He was a frail
child, with a shyness that he learned to hide but never overcame. In
1916 he
went to Eton as a King's Scholar; the future George Orwell was in the
same
election. In his first year, however, Runciman grew seven inches and
his
worried parents kept him at home for much of the remainder of his
schooldays. He passed the time reading history books.
Consequently, when he did see his teachers he thought them ill-informed.
"I
wish this boy was kinder to me," read one master's report.
In 1921, Runciman went up as a History scholar to Trinity College,
Cambridge. There he found in the fashionable pose of aesthete a mask
for his
diffidence. Among those invited to take roseleaf jam in his rooms -
home to
a large green parakeet named Benedict - were two other beautiful young
men,
the aspiring arbiters of taste Stephen Tennant and Cecil Beaton.
Beaton hastened to copy Runciman's liking for Fair Isle sweaters and
used
him as one of his first models, photographing him with a budgerigar
on his
finger.
Runciman took every opportunity to travel, visiting Istanbul for the
first
time in 1924. There he was told by a gypsy, correctly, that he would
have
several illnesses but live to a ripe old age. Runciman had a lifelong
fascination with the supernatural (and the naturally superior); he
later
read the tarot for King Fuad of Egypt and became court fortune teller
to
King George II of the Hellenes.
On graduating in 1924, Runciman approached practically the only scholar
then
interested in Byzantine studies, J B Bury, and asked to be his pupil.
Bury
initially refused, relenting only when he learned that Runciman could
read
Russian; he promptly thrust articles in Bulgarian at him and told him
to
come back in two weeks.
Later lessons proved difficult to arrange, as Bury's overprotective
wife
took the precaution of burning all letters addressed to him. Runciman
was
reduced to waylaying Bury during his daily walk along the Backs.
Runciman's dissertation on a 10th-century Byzantine emperor secured
him a
Fellowship at Trinity in 1927, and provided material for his first
two
books, The Emperor Romanus Lecapenus (1929) and The First Bulgarian
Empire
(1930).
His researches had, however, been interrupted by pleurisy, and in 1925
he
recuperated by sailing to China. In Peking, he was summoned to play
piano
duets with the ex-Emperor, Henry Pu Yi, who told him that he had chosen
his
forename out of fondness for the Tudors; his chief concubine, whom
he hated,
was named Bloody Mary.
When Runciman returned to Cambridge, he found that the college servant
with
whom he had boarded his parakeet refused to relinquish the bird, telling
him
sternly: "Polly likes it here."
Runciman taught at Cambridge until 1938 and was fondly regarded by his
students, among them Noel Annan and Guy Burgess. He also continued
to travel
widely, collecting people and places. His charm brought him friends
that
included George Seferis, Benjamin Britten and Edith Wharton, while
his taste
for exalted company brought encounters with, among others, the royal
houses
of Bulgaria, Romania, Siam and Spain.
He saw much of the world before it subscribed to a uniform culture.
In 1934
he visited Bulgaria, encountering the Istanbul-bound Patrick Leigh
Fermor,
and on the way back from Mount Athos, Greece, in 1937 helped to deliver
a
baby. It was, he said, "a sight no innocent bachelor should see".
In Siam he saw a ghost, which dissolved before his eyes, but missed
lunch
with Bao Dai when the young ruler of Vietnam broke his leg playing
football;
"not," thought Runciman, "a suitable pastime for an Emperor."
During the Holy Fire ceremony in Jerusalem at Easter 1931, he and Princess
Alice, who were seated in a gallery, amused themselves by dropping
molten
wax from their candles on to the bald patch below of the unpopular
garrison
commander; the irate soldier was the future Field-Marshal Montgomery.
In 1937 Runciman inherited a substantial sum from his grandfather. This
gave
him the freedom to surrender his Fellowship and concentrate on writing
books. When the Second World War broke out, he was recovering from
severe
dysentery and his health meant that he was only offered the untaxing
job of
censoring letters written by the Army's Cypriot muleteers. Burgess
got him a
job instead with the Ministry of Information and he was soon back in
Bulgaria as press attache.
Runciman always denied that he had in fact been a spy there, but in
the
records of the Italian Secret Service, which fell into British hands,
he was
rated "molto intelligente e molto pericoloso".
In 1941 the Germans advanced on Sofia, and Runciman narrowly escaped
death
when a bomb exploded in the Istanbul hotel to which he had been evacuated.
The device, concealed in the embassy luggage, had been set to explode
aboard
the train from Sofia; but the train reached Istanbul an hour early,
and the
bomb killed eight people in the lobby as Runciman was inspecting his
room.
In 1942 Runciman was appointed, at the Turkish government's request,
Professor of Byzantine Art and History at Istanbul University. There
he
researched his history of the Crusades. Having used his diplomatic
contacts
to smooth the accession of the young leader of the order, he was also
made
an honorary Whirling Dervish.
From 1945 until 1947 Runciman headed the British Council in Greece,
and from
1960 until 1975 he was President of the British Institute of Archaeology
at
Ankara, but after the war he concentrated principally on his writing.
Among his later books was his only excursion into modern history, a
biography of the White Rajahs of Sarawak commissioned by the Colonial
Office, but more notable were The Fall of Constantinople, 1453 (1965)
and a
compelling analysis of the massacre in 1282 that ended Charles of Anjou's
hopes of controlling the Mediterranean, The Sicilian Vespers (1958).
His study of dualist heresies, The Medieval Manichee (1947), remains
a
standard work, while Byzantine Style and Civilisation (1975) is an
exemplary
introduction to the subject.
Although he disliked public speaking, Runciman took up many requests
to give
lectures so as to see new places, especially in America. In Alaska
in 1970
he visited Eskimos who still followed the Russian Orthodox rite, and
at Las
Vegas when he played the slot machines he twice hit the jackpot.
Runciman later became fond of the sunshine of Bahrain, but Greece remained
his first love. He was chairman of the Anglo-Hellenic League (1951-67),
and
was instrumental in restoring the ill-maintained grave of Rupert Brooke
on
the island of Skyros.
He was much honoured by the Greeks, who named a street after him in
the
well-preserved Byzantine town of Mistras. He also became Grand Orator
of the
Greek Church, historically the senior lay member of the Patriarch's
synod.
For many years he kept a house in St John's Wood, London, where he gave
garden parties, but after he and his brother sold the island of Eigg,
which
they owned, in 1966, he made his base a peel tower in Dumfriesshire.
There he kept hens and an excellent collection of drawings, including
sketches of Greece by Edward Lear. He was a Councillor Emeritus of
the
National Trust of Scotland.
His partial memoirs, A Traveller's Alphabet (1991), recalled places
he had
visited from Athos to Zion, but revealed little of himself. In person
he
possessed courtesy, wit and culinary skill, and could, when treated
as the
fusty academic that he was not, deploy an armoury of filthy stories.
Four
hundred guests came to his 90th birthday party; his cake took the shape
of
the greatest of all Byzantine churches, Hagia Sophia.
In 1999, he presented the London Library (of which he was the
longest-serving life member) with a much needed new lift. A plaque
within in
it bears his name and the Latin inscription Plurimi pertransibunt et
multiplex erit scientia (the Vulgate version of Daniel xii 4: "Many
shall
run to and fro and knowledge shall be increased").
Earlier this year, aged 97, he made a final visit to Mount Athos to
witness
the blessing of the Protaton Tower at Karyes (the capital of the monastic
community), which had been refurbished thanks to a gift from him.
Steven Runciman was knighted in 1958 and appointed a Companion of Honour
in
1984. He was elected a Fellow of the British Academy in 1957.
He remained a bachelor, but liked the idea of marrying an elderly Spanish
Duchess in order to become a Dowager Duke; the title, he felt, would
have
rather suited him.
BYLINE: Philip Mansel
STEVEN RUNCIMAN was the leading British specialist in the history
of the
Byzantine Empire and the Crusades.
He had a romantic love of the Middle Ages since early childhood. For
Runciman, history was above all a story, "the only form of learning
that is
entirely about human beings" (animals, vegetables and minerals were
firmly
excluded). He wrote in the preface to his celebrated three-volume A
History
of the Crusades (1951-54): "I believe that the supreme duty of the
historian
is to write history, that is to say, to attempt to record in one sweeping
sequence the greater events that have swayed the destinies of men."
Although he had followed Crusader routes across Turkey and Syria, he
admitted that he had never found new archival material of value, indeed
that
he was "not very good at reading manuscripts": he concentrated on style
instead, modelling himself, for simplicity and picturesqueness, on
Beatrix
Potter. He typed surrounded by his sources, "muttering because I want
to get
the sound right. I think a book isn't well written unless it can be
read
aloud."
He succeeded in interesting members of the general reading public, as
well
as other historians, in such distant realms as the Despotate of the
Morea
and the Principality of Antioch, in the genealogies of the feudal families
of Outremer and the intrigues which led to the massacres of Frenchmen
in the
Sicilian Vespers. Gore Vidal wrote: "To read an historian like Sir
Steven
Runciman is to be reminded that history is a literary art quite equal
to
that of the novel."
Runciman claimed to have made more money for his publishers, Cambridge
University Press (which also publishes the Bible), than any author
except
God.
James Cochran Stevenson Runciman came from a world of power and wealth.
His
father, Walter Runciman (later first Viscount Runciman of Doxford),
was
President of the Board of Trade in the Asquith cabinet; his parents
were the
first married couple to be MPs at the same time. He went to Eton and
Trinity
College, Cambridge, where he was photographed by Cecil Beaton. Beaton
later
wrote: "When I photographed Steven Runciman wearing his thick black
hair in
a fringe, with a budgerigar (in fact a parakeet called Benedict) poised
on
his ringed finger, looking obliquely into the camera in the manner
of the
Italian primitives, I knew I had not lived in vain."
At Cambridge, Runciman was the first and only pupil of the celebrated
Byzantine historian J.B. Bury, whom he described as "not at all welcoming".
G.M. Trevelyan advised him that, if he wanted to write, he should leave
Cambridge. In 1929-30 he covered most of Greece on foot.
A bachelor and a younger son with a private income ("There's a lot to
be
said for being a younger son"), by the age of 30 Runciman had published
three learned and original books: The Emperor Romanus Lecapenus and
his
Reign (1929), The First Bulgarian Empire (1930) and Byzantine Civilisation
(1933).
His work was helped by his love of languages: he knew Bulgarian, Russian
and
Turkish as well as Greek, Latin and French. He preferred Greek to Latin
since he considered it "a much more flexible language", and the Byzantines
to be more civilised than the Western Europeans.
Runciman was also a historian of religion. Himself fascinated by Greek
Orthodox doctrine and mysticism, which he considered humbler and wiser
than
Western theology, he wrote books on medieval manicheism, the schism
between
the Latin and Greek churches and the Greek church under the Ottoman
sultans
(in which he pointed out "if absolute power corrupts, so too does absolute
impotence"). Although he was a specialist in the Greek and Latin East,
he
was no bigot. He called the Crusades "a vast fiasco . . . one of the
last
and most disastrous of the Barbarian invasions", and lamented the fall
of
the Ottoman Empire.
Few historians have enjoyed such an international life - as he revealed
in
his partial memoirs A Traveller's Alphabet (1991). They proceed from
Mount
Athos, via memories of Cambodia and Yucatan, to end in Zion. During
the
Second World War Runciman was Press Attache in Sofia (on the recommendation
of Guy Burgess) and Film Censor in Palestine. Later he taught at the
universities of Istanbul, Baghdad, Oxford and Cambridge. Two of his
best
books were The Fall of Constantinople, 1453 (1965) and an account of
the
Orthodox Church under the Ottoman Empire, The Great Church in Captivity
(1968). Partly in gratitude for these works, the Patriarch of Constantinople
appointed him Grand Orator of the Great Church. In Syria he became
an
honorary whirling dervish; in Mistra a street was named after him.
Steven Runciman was tall, slim and mild-looking. At the age of 14 he
had
been informed by Mrs Asquith: "My dear boy, it isn't that you've got
bad
manners, it's that you've got no manners at all."
Since he believed, as he told David Plante, in the duty to "talk and
listen,
to be engaged and engaging", he soon acquired manners, and friends.
His
acquaintances included Lady Ottoline Morrell, Lawrence of Arabia -
who
inspired feelings of mistrust and physical repulsion - Sophia Loren,
the
Regent of Iraq ("rather a silly man"), the Ruler of Bahrain and Prince
Louis
of Hesse, a cousin by marriage: "He was, I think, the most civilised
man
that I have ever known."
Runciman himself had the sense of understatement, and the sceptical
intonation, occasionally slightly plaintive, of his class and generation:
he
could make a monosyllable such as "there" sound as if it contained
three
vowels. Shy but gregarious, self-assured and formidable, he frequently
entertained friends at Elsieshields, a large white Scottish house complete
with arrow- slits and turrets, which was decorated with water-colours
of
Greece by Edward Lear and views of Istanbul by the younger van de Velde.
Most of his cooking and cleaning, like his travelling, was done alone.
The fascination of his conversation, revealed to a wider public in an
excellent 1987 television programme, Bridge to the East, came from
his
ability to ignore conventional limits of time and space. He would switch
from Thailand before the war, where "life was rather lively" and he
felt
like Gulliver in Lilliput, to the rows between Winston and Clementine
Churchill. Dinner with Queen Marie of Roumania in her castle in Transylvania
was described with as much zest as a debauched Halloween party in Alaska
40
years later.
He was delighted to be called a snob - "Clio, the muse of history, was
an
awful snob" - and had few rivals as a source of royal anecdotes. One
described Queen Elizabeth of the Belgians, the first queen to have
her face
lifted, who was given a smile so ecstatic that, when her husband died
in a
climbing accident, it had to be "let down" before the funeral. He remembered
playing the piano with the last Emperor of China, and had met families
from
the Caucasus who referred to the Virgin Mary as Aunt Mary.
Among his many honours he was Chairman of the Anglo-Hellenic League
from
1951 to 1967, President of the British Institute of Archaeology at
Ankara
from 1960 to 1975, and a Companion of Honour. Peter Maxwell Davies
dedicated
Eight Songs for a Mad King to him, and he was knighted in 1958.
By the end of his life, hailed as "our greatest living narrative historian",
he could say: "I suppose one has become a sort of celebrity up to a
certain
point."
When my wife and I last visited Steven Runciman in the spring at his
beloved
home at Elsieshields, the restored tower house near Lockerbie, he was
tearful about the parlous condition of the Serb people and the destruction
and damage inflicted on so many of their churches, writes Tam Dalyell.
In particular, he was concerned about the Patriarchate of Pec, the monastery
at Decani, the cathedral at Prizren, and the nunnery of Gracanica.
My last
telephone call to him was to report on my visit to Gracanica in June,
escorted by the Royal Scots Dragoon Guards. Runciman sighed: "If Gracanica
is, as you tell me, reduced to a Serb enclave, it is certain that some
time
this century the Serbs will inaugurate military action to retake Kosovo."
He
was always concerned about the future, however many anecdotes he would
tell
about his experience of life in the British elite, in the early years
of the
20th century.
Sir Patrick Cormack MP, chairman of the parliamentary All Party Arts
and
Heritage Group, regularly had lunch with Runciman at the Athenaeum:
"Only
three months ago he was still at the table in the club dining room,
composing mischievous limericks about current personalities."
David Winfield, who delivered the Rhind Lectures at Edinburgh in 1972
on
Cypriot mosaics and wall-paintings, and the day before yesterday delivered
one of the Frank Davies Memorial Lectures at the Courtauld Institute
in
London on the conservation of Byzantine paintings, recalls: "Steven
Runciman
was extremely generous with advice - and often personal money - to
young
postgraduates and scholars endeavouring to start an academic career
in the
art history of the Orthodox world."
One of his abiding interests was the life of the monks of Mount Athos,
which
he hoped would continue unchanged until Eternity. Runciman expressed
not the
remotest sympathy when he heard that the All Party Heritage Group's
visit to
Athos in 1996 had resulted in the males' being welcomed and lunched
by the
monks while the formidable ladies of the group, such as Baroness Lockwood,
former Chairman of the Equal Opportunities Commission, Baroness David,
Baroness Hilton of Eggardon, former Commander of the Metropolitan Police,
and Dame Jill Knight MP were confined to a boat which was to come no
nearer
the monasteries than 500 metres offshore.
Runciman was always sad that so many professional scholars tended to
dismiss
his work as that of a moneyed amateur. However, anyone who came in
contact
with him as President of the British Institute of Archaeology at Ankara
over
many years must know that he remained the deeply serious scholar who
wrote
the epic history of the Crusades.
It was a tradition that at each Feast held by Trinity College, Cambridge,
he
could invite a guest, who would stay in the room adjoining his on the
top
floor of the Master's Lodge. As one of his guests in the early 1990s
I could
see at first hand his astonishing zest for contemporary affairs. Also,
his
astonishing physical resilience. In his middle nineties he would still
come
to the Edinburgh Festival, and climb the 80 steps to the top- floor
flat of
his friend the art historian Nicholas Phillipson.
Runciman was a daily reader of Independent obituaries, "a connoisseur",
as
he put it. He took unashamed delight in outliving not only his own
contemporaries, but his friends and acquaintances of the following
generation. He actually asked me when he was 90 if I would promise
to
contribute to his own obituary in The Independent, with the remark,
"It will
be this year because a palmist in Bulgaria told me of my fate." Runciman's
unquenchable spirit defeated the palmist. He would chuckle with delight
that
he had won.
James Cochran Stevenson Runciman, historian: born 7 July 1903; Fellow,
Trinity College, Cambridge 1927-38 (Honorary Fellow 1965); Lecturer,
Cambridge University 1932-38; Professor of Byzantine Art and History,
University of Istanbul 1942-45; British Council Representative, Greece
1945-47; Chairman, Anglo-Hellenic League 1951 -67; FRSL 1952; Kt 1958;
President, British Institute of Archaeology at Ankara 1960-75; Chairman,
National Trust for Greece 1977-84; CH 1984; CLit 1987; died Radway,
Warwickshire 1 November 2000.
Sir Steven Runciman
Historian whose magisterial works
transformed our understanding of
Byzantium, the medieval church
and the crusades
Nigel Clive
Friday November 3, 2000
Sir Steven Runciman, the historian, aesthete and traveller, who has
died aged
97, was the pre-eminent British specialist of the Byzantine empire
and of the
crusades. His three-volume A History Of The Crusades, published between
1951
and 1954, set out to exemplify his belief that the main duty of the
historian was "to
attempt to record, in one sweeping sequence, the greater events and
movements that have swayed the destinies of man," and show that history's
aim was to give a deeper understanding of humanity. He aimed as much
at a non-
specialist audience as at fellow academics.
For Runciman, the crusades were the last of the barbarian invasions;
their disaster
was their failure to understand Byzantium."High ideals were besmirched
by cruelty
and greed, enterprise and endurance by a blind and narrow self-righteousness,"
he
wrote, "and the holy war itself was nothing more than a long act of
intolerance in the
name of God, which is a sin against the holy ghost."
Runciman was the second son of the 1st Viscount Runciman of Doxford,
who was
descended from the mid 18th- century Scottish painter, Alexander Runciman.
His father was a member of Asquith's cabinet and his mother was MP
for St
Ives. He himself always welcomed the fact that, as the younger son,
he was not
obliged to go either into politics or the family's shipping business.
Indeed, an
academic career was foreshadowed by his precocious ability to read
French at
three, Latin at six, Greek at seven and Russian at 11.
He won a scholarship to Eton, where a combination of an early interest
in Greece
and medievalism led naturally to his study of Byzantium. His school
friends included
Cyril Connolly, George Orwell and "Puffin" Asquith, the prime minister's
son.
In 1921, a further scholarship took him to Trinity College, Cambridge,
where he
began to demonstrate an elegant and fashionable aestheticism by papering
his
rooms with a French grisaille wallpaper depicting Cupid and Psyche,
and being
photographed by his friend, Cecil Beaton, with a parrot poised on his
ringed finger.
Through his school friend George Rylands, he was introduced to John
Maynard
Keynes, Lytton Strachey and Virginia and Leonard Woolf, and got to
know the
Bloomsbury group.
After taking a first in history, Runciman became a research student
of the
notoriously elusive JB Bury, the first British historian to take Byzantium
seriously. He artfully discovered the regius professor's regular habit
of taking an
afternoon walk along the Backs, and was thus able to manoeuvre Bury
into giving
him unofficial tutorials.
Following an attack of pleurisy - and his doctor's prescription that
his best chance
of recovery would come from a long sea voyage - he went to China, arriving
in the
middle of the civil war. But this did not prevent him from befriending
the last
Chinese emperor, with whom he played piano duets.
In 1924, Runciman made his first trip to Greece, was enchanted by the
Byzantine
town of Monemvasia and, later, by the old city of Istanbul. On his
return to
Cambridge, he concentrated on his fellowship thesis, with pioneering
investigations into Armenian and Syriac sources, which, in 1929, resulted
in his
first book, The Emperor Romanus Lecapenus. After that, in quick
succession, came The First Bulgarian Empire and Byzantine Civilisation.
Runciman had gone back to Trinity in 1927 to teach and hold a fellowship
until
1938. His first pupil had been Guy Burgess, whom he remembered for
his
intellectual brilliance and his dirty fingernails. His last pupil was
Donald
Nicol, who became Koraes professor of modern Greek and Byzantine history
at
London University. Meantime, his travels had taken him to Jerusalem
and Thailand,
with several more visits on foot and muleback to Greece and Turkey.
When his grandfather died in 1938, Runciman could afford to give up
his
fellowship, and take George Trevelyan's advice to leave Cambridge and
concentrate on his writing. By a happy chance, the war took him back
to the
countries of his choice, first as press attaché in Sofia in
1940, then to Cairo and
Jerusalem for the Ministry of Information, and finally to Istanbul
for three years as
professor of Byzantine art and history. This gave him the opportunity
to follow the
tracks of the crusaders and plan his History Of The Crusades - as well
as
visiting Syria and becoming an honorary whirling dervish.
Immediately after the war, Runciman willingly accepted the offer to
direct the
work of the British Council in Greece. During the next two years, assisted
by
Paddy Leigh Fermor and Rex Warner, this remarkable triumvirate endeared
themselves to the Greeks in a manner that has never been rivalled.
In Athens,
Runciman became a well-known figure in the smart Kolonaki set ("the
good bandit
families", as he characteristically called the descendants of the leaders
of the
Greek war of independence) and was a friend of George Sepheriades,
the
diplomat whose poetry, under the name of Sepheris, later won a Nobel
prize. In his
spare time, he improved his collection of icons, tanagras (figurines)
and Edward
Lears.
A fter the publication, in 1947, of The Medieval Man- ichee, a still
unchallenged
study of the Christian dualist heresy, Runciman returned to Britain
to start work
on the crusades, dividing his time between his house in St John's Wood,
London, and the isle of Eigg, off the Scottish coast, which his father
had
bought in 1926. From 1951 to 1967, he was chairman of the Anglo-Hellenic
League, which he nicknamed "the Anglo-Hell".
His reputation was triumphantly established when A History Of The
Crusades was published in three volumes, between 1951 and 1954. Praising
the
pace and style of its narrative history, some critics even compared
its author to
Macaulay.
The Eastern Schism was published in1955, and The Sicilian Vespers in
1958.
This was the year in which Runciman was knighted, and in 1961 he was
made a
knight commander of the Greek Order of the Phoenix. As part of his
continuing
revival of interest in Byzantium, The Fall of Constantinople: 1453,
appeared in 1965,
The Great Church In Captivity in 1968, The Last Byzantine Renaissance
in 1970, The
Orthodox Churches And The Secular State in 1972, and Byzantine Style
And
Civilization in 1975.
When a street was named after him in Mistra, his expression of gratitude
took
the form of a book, published in 1980, about the Byzantine capital
of the
Peloponnese.
Runciman had always found theology both fascinating and entertaining.
Although he
did not belong to the Orthodox church, he had a profound commitment
to orthodoxy
and believed that it enshrined the future of Christianity.
When Eigg was sold in 1966, he quickly moved to Elshieshields, a border
tower in
Dumfrieshire. Indeed, throughout his long and peripatetic life, he
had always known
that his roots were in Scotland. This became his last home, where he
happily
entertained both old and new friends, introducing them to his collection
of 18th-
and 19th-century musical boxes, worry beads, a hubble bubble, the Alexander
Runcimans and Edward Lears, the limericks as well as the watercolours.
Here, too, he could display his knowledge of the gen- ealogical ramifications
of
European royalty, often flavoured by well-informed gossip. The year
after his
80th birthday he was made a companion of honour.
But although he settled in Scotland and made only irregular visits to
London,
Runciman still found time to travel abroad to lecture and discover
new Coptic
churches. In 1987, his name and fame reached a much wider audience
when
Channel 4 produced a well-directed verbal autobiography, Sir Steven
Runciman:
Bridge To The East."
Even in his middle 80s, there was no slackening of his energy or intellectual
vitality, and his ability to charm his friends of all ages. Early in
1991, an exhibition of
his collection of Lear's watercolours was held at the National Gallery
of Scotland.
The catalogue contained his introduction and comments on each of the
pictures, as
well as a photograph of Stephen Conroy's portrait of him, which hangs
in the
Scottish Nat- ional Portrait Gallery. Soon afterwards, he published
A Traveller's
Alphabet: Partial Memoirs, which colourfully recorded in alphabetical
form -
A for Athos, Z for Zion - a lifetime of travels that had taken him
round the
world, and "where a certain amount of serendipity had crept in".
In 1992, Runciman redis covered a short story or novella, written in
1935 and
entitled Paradise Regained. This fictional account of an expedition
to Iraqi
Kurdistan, dedicated to George Rylands and revealing both his wit and
sharp
sense of humour, was privately printed and distributed to his friends
in place of a
Christmas card.
In 1993, to celebrate his 90th birthday, dinners were given for him
by the Old
Collegers of Eton, by the British Byzantines and by Trinity College,
Cambridge. The Cambridge University Press organised a reception for
him, and
the National Trust for Scotland gave him its guest flat at Culzean
in Ayrshire.
Finally, he invited some hundreds of friends to a a lavish reception
at Spencer
House.
All the while, Runciman continued to travel. In September 1994, he took
part in
the ceremony on the island of Lemnos inaugurating the Aegean declaration,
an
agreement between Unesco and the Greek Ministry of Culture to turn
the
Greek archipelago into a European cultural park. In April 1995, in
his capacity
as president of the Friends of Mount Athos, he published a learned
article in
the Times deploring the fact that, on the Athonite peninsula, the tradition
of faith
transcending ethnic difference, which had been the practice for more
than a
millennium, was under threat.
As late as 1997, besides his regular visits to Bahrain and Greece, he
contributed a
sparkling review in the Spectator of a life of Marthe Bibesco, the
Wallachian
princess who was a confidante of countless heads of state. As recently
as
last month, he was in Athens to receive from the Greek president the
international
prize for culture (arts and humanities) of the Onassis Foundation.
In addition to its
silver trophy, he received $125,000, which he generously offered to
Mount Athos.
Runciman was greatly distressed by the Kosovo war, where his sympathies
lay
with the Serbs. When well on in his 90s, he began writing his memoirs.
He never
married.
James Cochran Stevenson Runciman,
historian, aesthete and traveller, born July 7 1903; died November
1 2000