Exploring Solution Spaces © Copyright 2003-2006, by C. Keith Ray
   


About
Exploring Solution Spaces, Keith Ray's blog on Software development and other topics.

Send comments to:
keithray@mac.com

For Agile Training, eLearning, or Coaching contact:
Industrial Logic, Inc.
866-540-8336 (toll free)
510-540-8336 (Berkeley, California)

Links
xpminifaq
Résumé
“Adopting XP” Article 2002 (pdf)
“ Refactoring” Article 2006
AYE Conference
Lucien W. Dupont
Elisabeth Hendrickson
Johanna Rothman's Managing Product Development
Brian Marick's Exploration Through Example
Esther Derby's Insights You Can Use
Laurent Bossavit's Incipient(thoughts)
Dale Emery's Conversations with Dale
Martin Fowler's Bliki
Creating Passionate Users

Archives

  • 2003
  • 2004
  • 2005
  • 2006
  • 2007
  • 2008
  • Subscribe
    RSS Exploring Solution Spaces XML


           
    2004.Nov.09 Tue

    Debate instead of Dialog 2

    More advice for dealing software people: if you offer an idea or suggestion to "debaters" (see previous blog entry), and they poke a dozen holes in it, that means that they're interested in it. Try to imagine that they are trying to help you, because many times this is their way of doing that.

    To move from debate into dialog, ask them to how to resolve one of the problems they just brought up. This will (if they are interested) switch their mode to "problem-solver", which is one of their favorite modes.

    [/docs] permanent link

    Debate Instead of Dialog

    Many people in the software biz respond to an attempt at conversation with a rebuttal. This isn't dialog, it's debate. It's one of the reasons software developers have developed a reputation for poor social skills. Do you do this? Here's a symptom: your replies to someone else often start with the word "but". Examples:

    Dialogger: "It was raining this morning."

    Debater: "But it's not raining now."


    Dialogger: "We could have found this bug a long time ago if we had written a unit test for [some condition]."

    Debater: "But unit tests can't find all bugs."


    By starting with "but", you don't give credit to the other person for their idea, even if you agree with it. Try restating their ideas before responding with your ideas or disagreements.

    [/docs] permanent link