|
Introduction
Until iChat came along, video conferencing
on a Mac computer wasn’t particularly easy. Finding a supported
camera and drivers, finding application software – getting a working
system wasn’t much fun, and the results were variable.
Now, thanks to iChat, not only is it straightforward
and easy to use, but the results blow away all competing systems. Using
iChat
makes other computer-based
and standalone systems look antiquated. Once you’ve used iChat to
talk to someone on the other side of the world, with it’s full-screen,
TV speed frame rate and high quality sound, you’ll understand why
using iChat is so much better than any other system.
However, to operate, iChat needs a broadband internet link and a fast
Mac at both ends, and unfortunately not everyone has that luxury. If
you are interested
in other solutions, or linking a Mac to a PC, then this website is for
you. It contains all the information I’ve amassed in the several years I’ve
been experimenting with Mac and PC video conferencing. Good luck!
My Story
Do to family requirements, my goal has always been a good quality, Mac-based
video conferencing system linking Seattle in the US with Belfast in N. Ireland,
Europe. The Seattle side of the equation was an flat screen iMac, connected
via Airport to a DSL connection. The Belfast side was an iBook connected via
modem. The modem was a serious bottleneck.

After much experimentation, the best program for the job turned out
to be an application called SquidCam. SquidCam is a great program with
a lot work
behind it. It has the advantages of working over a slow link (such
as a modem) and having both Mac and Windows clients. For a year or so,
this was the way
my weekly video calls were made. 
Then Apple released iChat, and things changed. The quality of iChat
is amazing – the catch is that it requires broadband connections
at both ends. This prompted the upgrading of the Belfast side to DSL,
and as
a result, iChat is now the application of choice and the quality
has improved dramatically.

I don’t want to run SquidCam down – it’s still cross-platform,
something that iChat can’t do, but for ease of use and quality,
iChat has to be the program of choice on Mac-only set-ups. If you
don’t
have broadband at both ends, or one of you uses a PC, definitely
check out SquidCam.
You should also try iVisit - another cross-platform program that
operates over modem speeds as well as broadband and LANs. iVisit is available in a "lite" form that's free to use.
Your story
Whatever you want to achieve with your
video conferencing plans, before you even get started, you should know
what's involved. Here is a brief summary of what you'll need.
- Apple computer running OS X 10.2 or
10.3. Jaguar and Panther support cameras better than previous
versions of OS X.
- Compatible webcam (Firewire, DV
Camcorder, or USB camera)
- Driver software for webcam (not
required with a Firewire camera)
- Microphone. Some Macs and come
cameras have built-in
microphones, some don't.
- Internet connection. Broadband is a
lot better than modem, and I'm not kidding.
- Someone else to talk to! :-)
If you and your friend have a Mac capable of running iChat, then do it - it's by far the best solution available. Although
it's easier if both parties have Macs, if you need to talk to someone
who is using Windows or Linux, there are solutions. Check out the
cross-platform options in the column to the right.
Video Conferencing Software
You have all the hardware you need? Now it's time for the software. There
are both free and commercial solutions available, and if you want cross-compatibility
with Windows, that's available too. Check out the list to the right.
However, the big news is that now Apple have their own solution, and it
rocks!
Cross Platform Video
Conferencing
A common question is "How can I perform a
video conference with a PC user?". Sadly, iChat is not available for
Windows, and MSN Messenger for Mac does not support video (or sound). One
ray of hope is that the link between AOL and iChat may mean video will be
supported in the future (AOL was unable to provide video in their chat
programs until recently, under court order. Rumors are buzzing about new
software coming from AOL or even an iChat port to Windows!).
However, there are solutions available right
now that will allow you to see and hear your PC owning friends. And if these
programs aren't suitable, you can always set up a webcam so they can at
least see you while you type messages using MSN Messenger or iChat.
| Mac Software |
PC
Software |
Comments |
|
SquidCam |
SquidCam |
Works well over broadband
connections. Commercial. |
|
ohphoneX |
NetMeeting |
Windows users all have
NetMeeting
installed - run "conf" from the Start
menu. Results are ok rather than great.
Free. |
|
ohphoneX |
GnomeMeeting |
If your PC users are
Linux fans,
they'll probably already have
GnomeMeeting installed. Free. |
| SightSpeed |
SightSpeed |
Clients for both Mac and PCs, costs $4.95 a month. Free
trial version available. |
|
iVisit |
iVisit |
Commercial product, with a "lite"
version for free. Works over modems as well as broadband.Definitely
worth trying, even if the user interface is a little 1980's
;-) |
|
MarratechPro |
MarratechPro |
Requires a central
server, provides application sharing. Commercial. |
|
VChat |
CUSeeMe |
Picky to set up.
Free. |
|
ISPQ |
ISPQ |
Issues with sound
support, check latest version. Commercial. |
|
Yahoo!
messenger |
Yahoo!
messenger |
Slow video response,
no sound. Free. |
|
Ircle |
IRC client |
IRC based. Free. |
Camera hardware
Theoretically, it's possible to use
either USB or Firewire webcams with a Mac running OS X. In practice,
Firewire is recommended for better image quality and speed. USB cameras
require extra drivers, and compatibility is limited, so do NOT rush out
and buy a USB webcam without checking you can get drivers for it first.
Logitech have released drivers for many
of their QuickCam USB cameras!
Note: you can also use almost any
Firewire compatible Camcorder. Digital camcorders are dropping in price
all the time. Using a camcorder you could even send pre-recorded
material over the video link - for example, sending your holiday footage
to Grandma.

I bought the iBot, and it works perfectly
as a video source, with no extra drivers, on an iBook system 4000 miles
away. iMovie and Final Cut Pro did NOT detect this
camera - or any Webcam - which is a shame as it would have been easy to make little
movies. The reason is that Webcams don't stream video in DV format, which is what iMovie/FCP
require.
Camera Driver Software
The iSight doesn't require drivers when
used with Jaguar or Panther, just like almost all other Firewire cameras. However,
some cameras, particularly USB models,
do need extra software. You may need to pay for this. Jaguar/Panther support most
FireWire cameras (including Camcorders and FireWire WebCams) out-of-the-box.
If you don't have a compatible camera, check the list to the right for drivers.
Microphones
Just when you thought you had everything covered, you realize that
your particular Mac doesn't have a microphone - or even a socket to connect one to.
What are you going to do now? The answer is to use a camera with a mic,
or a USB based
microphone or microphone adaptor. There are several to choose from - and
even if your Mac does have a built-in microphone, a desk-top mike or
headset might give better results. If you use a camcorder, you can use the
camcorder's microphone as a source.
|
What's New
Fancy new website look.
This new design should make it easier for me to add new
content. Also, the blog is now an integral part of the
website.
iChat Beta Adds Support for AOL AIM
Apple have
just released a beta version of iChat that allows Mac
users to video conference with
AIM users with video and sound support! This is the
first ever Apple-supported cross-platform video conferencing
system! Download the demo and try it out with your PC owning
friends!
Capture your
iChat conversations
Thanks to
SnapzProX from Ambrosia Software, you can capture your
iChat conversations to disk. By the way,
check out this sample if you want to see how good iChat
looks compared to other video conferencing applications.
Chat with Windows users
Two new recommendations for cross-platform users: iVisit
Lite and SightSpeed. Both have PC and Mac clients available.
Talk to your Windows using buddies!
iLife
v4 Updates iMovie to Support iSight
If you have iLife v4, you’ll find that iMovie now has an extra
feature and can important video directly. After recording, it does
a little processing to convert it into the format iMovie
requires. This is a great way to
record snippets of video easily and quickly. Well done
Apple for listening to what users have been asking for!
SightLight
From Griffin Technology
If you are looking to improve your image, lighting is important.
This lighting system attaches to the iSight, and looks great.
MacMice and GCam
Free application GCam allows you to make mini movies
with your iSight. You can then download them into iMovie,
and export them as
Quicktime movies, you can get 10 secs of video for
about 768 Kb.
Complete Macam driver for Panther fix!
Macam now supports Panther! The Macam/ichatusbcam combination
allows g3 Macs and Macs with processor speeds as low
as 333 to work with iChat.
It's not pretty but it works ;-)
iSight problem?
- If you have an iSight and are experiencing issues with the
camera not being detected, see this
Apple service site.
|