Andrea Dworkin's Dead


The Malcolm X of feminism

This morning I discovered from Andrew Sullivan's web log, the Daily Dish, that Andrea Dworkin died two days ago at the age of 58. Sullivan, who could be called the father of the gay marriage movement, briefly commented on and quoted David Frum's obit:

They agreed on one important thing: the need to roll back sexual freedom:
And in one respect at least, she shared a deep and true perception with the political and cultural right: She understood that the sexual revolution had inflicted serious harm on the interests of women and children – and (ultimately) of men as well.

Ouch. Not that long ago I would have scoffed at such talk. Dworkin was that mad woman who hated sex and hated men. These days though, I'm reconsidering everything. I've seen too much death and too many damaged people to not have second thoughts.

Clicking over to Frum's posting I learn that he met Dworkin through Christopher Hitchens. And that she held at least one view that I could agree with whole heartedly:

Politically she belonged to the far, far, far left, but she had little use for an antiwar movement that made excuses for Saddam Hussein or Islamic extremism.

Frum linked to an "uneuphemistic obituary" in the New York Sun which sounded intriguing so I headed over there. Stephen Miller does a good job summing up Dworkin's influence, accomplishments and the source of her inspiration:

She was also perhaps the greatest solipsist of the women's movement. Dworkin's sexual politics (as a fellow pioneer, Kate Millet, termed them) emerged directly from her accounts of being violated as a child, raped as a teenager, beaten as a wife, and assaulted as a streetwalker. A prolific essayist and poet, Dworkin also wrote novels concerning a sexually brutalized young woman from New Jersey.

Dworkin's greatest strength was also her greatest weakness. She could see male sexuality only as a weapon. For her there was no sexual revolution, no freedom, only varying forms of oppression.

At the end of Miller's piece there came a ray of hope:

Susie Bright, the essayist, filmmaker, and authority on pornography, recalled Dworkin's influence yesterday on her Web log: "She was the one who got us looking at porn with a critical eye, she made you feel like you could just stomp into the adult bookstore and seize everything for inspection and a bonfire. The funny thing that happened on the way to the X-Rated Sex Palace was that some of us came to different conclusions than Miss Dworkin."

Susie Bright has a weblog! How did I miss that?

Bright is a pro-sex feminist, an enthusiastic advocate of recreational sex that is exciting, fun, safe and as far from Sullivan's gay marriage stereotype as you can get. Reading her homage to Dworkin reminded me that the sexual revolution was not a failure but remains an ongoing project.


Here’s the irony... every single woman who pioneered the sexual revolution, every erotic-feminist-bad-girl-and-proud-of-it-stiletto-shitkicker, was once a fan of Andrea Dworkin. Until 1984, we all were...

Andrea presented herself as a street fighter intellectual, a bohemian freedom fighter, and someone who wanted to get to the bottom of things. That quote about Malcolm X is apt. Malcolm pointed out  “The problem is WHITE PEOPLE.”  Dworkin said, “The problem is MEN.”  And for all the holes that can be poked in that cloth, there is something about that grain that is absolutely true, when you are the short end of the bolt.

I loved that she dared attack the very notion of intercourse. It was the pie aimed right in the crotch of Mr. Big Stuff. It was an impossible theory, but it wasn’t absurd. There is something about literally being fucked that colors your world, pretty or ugly, and it was about time someone said so.

I know it’s strange that I have such a tragic affection for her, when she apparently only had loathing for my kind. I’ve had women come at me with knives who felt they had to do me in, in Dworkin’s name. Her passion and activism was classic Prime of Miss Jean Brodie. She was a dangerous lady, with no class analysis, no psychological insight-- a scary combination. Her loaded warped pistol was neatly picked up by right wing creeps who took all the femme bullets out of it and never looked back...

I’m sorry Andrea Dworkin started a sexual revolution that she ended up repudiating. She never got to see people like me, Carol, and the rest of us little protégées who took her inspiration and flew to a new dimension. She got stuck, and then she got sick, and when you’re famous for one thing, no one wants to see you change unless you reject it all, like a pathetic sinner seeking redemption. She was too stubborn and too old-fashioned for that. Andrea Dworkin never would have admitted that she was a SuperStar.


Posted: Wed - April 13, 2005 at 08:09 AM          


©