'The affliction known as adolescence'When Canada adopted the Charter of Rights and
Freedoms back in the 1980s there was some debate about whether the voting age
should be lowered to 14. There was talk about a charter challenge in the courts,
but if it ever happened not much came of it. Today there seems to be a strong
opinion to the contrary – young people can't be trusted to make mature
decisions until around age
30.
Psychologist Robert Epstein has written a book challenging this view. The Case Against Adolescence: Rediscovering the Adult in Every Teen. Even though I think he's got the right idea I'm afraid it's too late to deschool society, and it's schools that are primarily responsible for creating immature adults. The Globe and Mail (curses, I'm tempted to
re-subscribe) looked at Epstein's argument with two articles in recent
weeks.
Margeret Wente in her column It's our fault they can't grow up says "The infantilization of our children has reached ridiculous extremes."
And Tralee Pearce in Adolescence is obsolete looks more specifically at the teen years and Epstein's prescription of more responsibility and less restriction as an antidote to the immaturity epidemic.
Rather than setting arbitrary ages for adulthood status Epstein wants to see competency tests.
The 112 comments that followed showed some Globe readers are appalled and others intrigued by such proposals. Perhaps there is some hope for the kids. With the shrinking population there's a silly idea going around that society should raise the retirement age and force us old folks to keep on working. Yah right, if you really want to see rebellion try that one. We've already got the vote remember, and we tend to use it. Work is for the young. We should return it to them. Thanks to Zonk for drawing these stories to my attention. Posted: Tue - August 28, 2007 at 10:09 AM |
Quick Links
A blog by Jim Monk
XML/RSS Feed
Archives
Calendar
Categories
My Favourite Blogs
My Favourite Sites
Subscriptions
Windsor - Essex Blogs
Statistics
Total entries in this blog:
Total entries in this category: Published On: Sep 12, 2007 03:13 PM |
||||||||||||||