Books

Stories

"Someday"
 
1956
Robot Story
2
 

Niccolo Mazetti is unhappy with his Bard, his story-telling computer. His friend Paul Loeb tries to upgrade the Bard and tells Niccolo about the wonderful possibilities opening up for him, including the learning of a forgotten art called "writing". The Bard manages to overhear this and, after they leave, tells a story to itself of its own pain.

I loved this story when I was young—I even tried to memorize it once. It has lots some of its luster over the years, however. I'm willing to grant the existence of a society where people cannot do arithmetic a la "The Feeling of Power", but I really have a hard time believing in a society without the written word. And, by today’s standards, Bards are rather primitive and uninteresting machines.

The main problem is the story is a little too strong on the pathos—perhaps just right for a preteen, but a bit sappy for someone older. Asimov pulls at the heart-strings far more effectively with "The Ugly Little Boy" than he does here in this competent, but not overwhelming, story.

Contents
32
Earth Is Room Enough
33
The Complete Robot
22
Robot Visions
33
Complete Stories, The, Vol. 1
 
Review copyright © 1995–2002 by John H. Jenkins. All rights reserved.
Last updated: JHJ