Breakthrough in Lindenwood Yard Design
I recently picked up a copy of Model Railroader's
Model Railroad Planning 2005. In that issue on page 80 is an article by Kenneth
Anthony titled Managing S curves. I read through the article and decided to
review my layout for lurking S curves. I knew I had a situation where the design
was less than optimal for two reasons. At the east end of my Lindenwood Yard,
the track curves around almost 90 degrees back towards the wall to head into the
closet and down the helix to the lower level. I had designed a crossover at that
end of the yard to allow an eastbound train to crossover from the left hand
mainline track to the right hand track. This does two things, it maintains right
hand running and has the train traverse the inside of the helix on its way down
to the lower level. The problem was, I placed that helix in a short section of
tangent track that ended up in the wall seperating the room from the closet. I
would have to mount switch machines and view the positions of the turnouts
inside the wall, not the best. Compounding the problem was that this created a
poor S curve situation. Crossovers create natural S curves, but I was curving
away and into the crossover from the wrong direction. After reading the MRP
article, I took a look at the plan and came up with a much better design. I
moved the crossover to the exit of the yard, and by using Ken's suggestions
actually eliminated the S curve. In addition, I added another crossover (also
without an S curve!) to provide a way for westbound trains to travel through the
yard on the left hand mainline. I can see a situation where a through train
might want to do that while a eastbound departing train is waiting or being made
up. Take a look at the two drawings from my layout design in 3rd Plan It and see
if you agree! Also, my thanks to Kenneth Anthony and Tony Koester and all the
folks who helped put this year's MRP together. That article alone was worth
every penny I invested.Layout Design
Before:
Layout Design
After:
Posted: Sun - March 20, 2005 at 01:50 PM