Popular Mythology



Over on the AEI website, Fred Kagan has a good article on how many myths are obstructing reasoned debate over how to proceed in Iraq.
The debate about American policy and strategy in Iraq has veered off course. A number of myths have crept into the discussion over the past two years that distort understanding and confuse discussion.... But constructive dialogue about how to choose the best way forward is hampered by the distortions caused by certain myths.

What might those myths be? You will probably recognize most of them....
Myth 1: The Bush administration intends to keep substantial U.S. forces in Iraq for a long time and must be pressured to bring them home quickly.
Myth 2: The presence of U.S. forces in Iraq is the major source of the conflict there. Peace will return to Iraq as Americans leave.
Myth 3: The war in Iraq is a distraction from the war on terrorism.
Myth 4: The wisdom of invading Iraq in 2003 should be an important part of the discussion about what to do in Iraq today.
Myth 5: Most Iraqis “want us out,” and we have lost the battle for “hearts and minds.” Therefore, we cannot succeed.
Myth 6: Setting a timetable for withdrawal will “incentivize” the Iraqis to take responsibility for their own country.

What we really need is an honest debate, not a polarized one where one side's arguments are built on false pretenses. We need to move "towards a more reasoned debate"...

(Hat Tip: Security Watchtower)

Posted: Sat - February 25, 2006 at 09:05 PM          


©