The US has Roe v. Wade. Canada has Dr. Henry Morgentaler. Twenty years ago, he took the fight for abortion rights to the Supreme Court and won. He's now been named to the Order of Canada, a well-deserved and long-postponed honour for this survivour of Auschwitz. His battle has been a long one, and as might be expected, still capable of generating a great deal of controversy.
In 1967, Morgentaler made his debut on the national stage and entered the abortion debate in a dramatic way. He testified before a government committee considering changes to the abortion law, advocating that any woman should have the right to end her pregnancy without risking death.
It was a bold statement. At the time, performing an abortion could land a doctor in jail with a life sentence. Women who had abortions faced imprisonment of up to two years.
Against that backdrop, Morgentaler at first refused requests to end pregnancies. But by 1969, he said he could refuse no longer. He opened an abortion clinic in Montreal and openly began performing abortions illegally — thousands of them. It was no secret; he gave interviews and even allowed TV news crews to film. He viewed the access to abortion as a simple matter of human rights.
Condemnation came quickly and on a variety of fronts. It didn’t take long for his first arrest.
He was subsequently acquitted by a jury. But the Quebec Court of Appeal overturned that acquittal and sentenced him to prison. He served 10 months in Montreal’s Bordeaux Jail.
The law was eventually changed so that a jury acquittal could no longer be overturned on appeal, another piece of Morgentaler's legacy.
There would, of course, be many more arrests, two more jury acquittals (one in Quebec and one in Ontario), at least eight raids on his clinics, one firebombing and huge legal bills.
As you may suspect, there is a lot of teeth-nashing and wailing in certain parts of the political spectrum. Today comes news that a priest in BC is
turning in his OoC so as not to be associated with him. Granted I enjoyed the Craven Jamboree Father Larre created back when he was in Saskatchewan, but he's
not exactly the kind of guy I'd want to be associated with anyway.
Father Larre, on the other hand, is probably best known for being convicted in 1992 on two counts of physically abusing children in his care at Bosco Homes in Saskatchewan: slapping and choking a female, and forcing another to take pills to teach her a lesson about drug abuse.
Nine other charges including one of sexual assault were overturned.
In 1998, Larre registered as a psychologist in B.C., but the B.C. College of Psychologists suspended his registration because it felt he posed "an immediate risk to the public."
I wonder how many of his fellow OoC recipients are happy he's returned the award?
As for the oh-so-tolerant Conservatives, they're doing everything in their power to distance themselves from this and
diminish the honour if they can.
MP Maurice Vellacott, a Conservative from Saskatchewan who opposes abortion, told the Globe and Mail on Monday that he heard Morgentaler's appointment was not unanimous.
"This is a pretty divisive issue," he said. "I think we can all agree on that, so why would we have the highest honour in the country being issued when there is obviously a strong difference of opinion about it?"
A strong difference of opinion over the award? What do you think Canadians thought about giving the award to
this guy? I didn't like him to begin with, and the fact that he destroyed the PC's as a force on the federal level is a major part of the reason the right got taken over by people unwilling to
acknowledge the honour.
The Harper government said it had nothing to do with the appointment, which was announced by the Governor General’s office on the advice of a high-powered committee.
“The Conservative government is not involved in either deliberations or decisions with respect to which individuals are appointed to the Order of Canada,” said a statement issued Tuesday evening by Dimitri Soudas, a spokesman for Harper.
They do know their base. On the other hand, I suppose this explains why the Cons are
losing their female supporters.