IPCura Announces the Most Valuable Patents in 2003


Abstract
An IP Consulting firm named IPCura has released a report detailing the most valuable patents thus far in 2003. The top 20 according to the website are:

1.    US 5742905         Personal Communications Internetworking                Bells Communications Res Inc.
2.    US 5608786         Unified messaging system and method                      Alphanet Telecom Inc.
3.    US 5643826         Method for manufacturing a semiconductor device   Semiconductor Energy Lab Co.
4.    US 5774660         World-wide-web server with delayed resource...         Resonate,Inc.
5.    US 5744305         Arrays of materials attached to a substrate                  Affymetrix, Inc.
6.    US 5884032         System for coordinating communications via...           New Bruswick Telephone Co.
7.    US 5837458         Methods and compositions for cellular and...              Maxygen, Inc.
8.    US 5862325         Computer-based communication system and...         Intermind Coroporation
9.    US 5143854         Large scale photolithographic solid phase...               Affymax Technologies
10.  US 5790548         Universal access multimedia data network                 Bell Atlantic Network Serv., Inc.
11.  US 5738574         Continuous processing system for chemical...           Applied Materials, Inc.
12.  US 5811238         Methods for generating polynucleotides having...       Affymax Technologies
13.  US 5380721         DNA mutagenesis by random fragmentation...           Affymax Technologies
14.  US 5605662         Active programmable electronic devices for...             Nanogen, Inc.
15.  US 5848396         Method and apparatus for determining behavioral...  Freedom of Informations, Inc.
16.  US 5610910         Access to telecommunications networks in...             Northern Telecom Limited
17.  US 5647168         Flat trapezoidal container of brightly printed...              Professional Package Co.
18.  US 5700637         Apparatus and method for analyzing polynucleotide  Isis Innovation Limited
19.  US 5807522         Methods for fabricating microarrays of biological...     Stanford University
20.  US 5683366         System and method for electrosurgical tissue...         Arthrocare Corporation

The problem with this is that no where on their site do they actually mention how they came up with this ranking or how they do their scoring. The entire effort is meant to promote the sale of a $999 report that outlines different companies and industries and rank their portfolios. Without a clearer understanding of the methodology behind the scores it is hard to say how valuable this information is.


A copy of the press release is included below:

"IPCURA ANNOUNCES THE MOST VALUABLE PATENTS IN 2003

Patents from Bell Communications Research, Affymetrix and Semiconductor Energy Laboratory Co. top the list.

San Clemente, CA, June 3, 2003 – Wireless text messaging, DNA chips and amorphous silicon fabrication are the most innovative, fastest growing technologies this year, according to a patent analysis report released today by IPCura, Inc.

The report tracks trends in technology progress in different sectors of industry and nonprofit research organizations. “Just five years ago, PCR (polymerase chain reaction) and web-related technology were the most valuable patents in biotechnology and communications,” said Anne Y. Brody, Ph.D., President of IPCura. “Now, DNA chips are the principle platform technology for drug discovery, and wireless text messaging has become the most popular way to communicate in the new millennium.”

While giant companies, such as IBM, Microsoft and Allergan, remain at the top with the most valuable patent portfolios, early-stage companies are developing cutting-edge technologies, changing the trends of their respective industries. The report also shows that Roche experienced a dramatic decrease in the value of its patent portfolio, ranking from No. 6 in 1999 to No. 17 in 2003, in the category of pharmaceuticals. In computer hardware, Hon Hai Precision Industry, a Taiwan-based electronics manufacturer, has dynamically improved the value of its patent portfolio from No. 25 to No. 14.

The University of California, the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and the California Institute of Technology have the most valuable patent portfolios for academic institutions. Trailing not far behind, Stanford University (from No. 18 to No. 6), the University of Washington (from No. 39 to No. 8) and Carnegie Mellon University (from No. 90 to No. 17) have aggressively boosted the value of their patent portfolios from 1999 to 2003.

The top 20 most valuable patents are listed at IPCura’s website at www.ipcura.com. The patent analysis report, which evaluates over 11,000 U.S. patents from ~1,900 corporations, is an essential resource for patent portfolio management, technology marketing and commercialization. For more information on the report, please call Anne Brody at 949-492-5642 or email info@ipcura.com.

About IPCura
IPCura, an intellectual property consulting firm, provides services in patent evaluation and technology transfer for academic institutions and corporations. Located in San Clemente, CA, IPCura supports clients in their intellectual property development, product strategy planning, research and development prioritization. IPCura Index Report is one of the most comprehensive analyses available on patents and technologies."

Posted: Fri - June 6, 2003 at 06:53 AM   Patinformatics   Vendor News   Email Comments


© Anthony Trippe